The wind or The Swift Hand of God? He has a way of letting us know exactly who is in charge.........................
George Gongora/Caller-Times Law enforcement officers inspect a car belonging to 105th District Court Judge J. Manuel Bañales on Thursday near the Interstate 37/Padre Island Drive interchange. Rescuers had to cut the roof and doors off the Cadillac DeVille to free Bañales, who, along with the transportation worker struck, was taken to the Christus Spohn Hospital Memorial.
George Gongora/Caller-Times Law enforcement officers inspect a car belonging to 105th District Court Judge J. Manuel Bañales on Thursday near the Interstate 37/Padre Island Drive interchange. Rescuers had to cut the roof and doors off the Cadillac DeVille to free Bañales, who, along with the transportation worker struck, was taken to the Christus Spohn Hospital Memorial.
A local judge's car hit a transportation department worker crouching near his truck about to fix a sign Thursday afternoon, sending the worker to the hospital in critical condition, police said.
A Texas Department of Transportation heavy-duty pickup with a cherry-picker lift was parked near a ramp connecting Padre Island Drive to southbound Interstate 37 when J. Manuel Bañales, 105th District Court judge and presiding judge of the Fifth Judicial Administrative District, entered the ramp. His gold Cadillac Deville slid off the pavement and struck the truck parked a few feet away on the grass.
Two workers had just pulled over to fix a small, directional black and yellow sign about 2:45 p.m., said police Capt. John Houston, when one worker spotted the Cadillac heading straight for the truck and jumped out of the way. Another worker, 34 years old, wasn't able to move.
"He was hit with the full force of the vehicle," Houston said. "He's injured head to toe."
That worker was rushed to Christus Spohn Hospital Memorial with life-threatening injuries. Late Thursday he was in emergency surgery and on a ventilator. Bañales' injuries are not believed to be life-threatening, police said. He was taken to the same hospital.
The ramp was closed until about 6 p.m. as Corpus Christi police and Texas Department of Public Safety troopers cataloged the accident.
Houston said officers responded to the accident just like any other of the same severity, and state troopers were called in to help re-create the accident.
It wasn't clear Thursday afternoon how fast the Cadillac was going or what caused the accident, Houston said.
The Cadillac came to rest in the wrong direction, with its roof and doors removed with the Jaws of Life. The truck was some 50 yards away, pushed halfway up an embankment to another ramp by the force of impact.
As officers combed the road and car, a yellow grate from the pickup with three orange cones and a water cooler sat a few feet away from the car's front bumper. The worker who jumped out of the way was just about to set up the cones when the car struck, a transportation department spokesman said.
Bañales has been a district judge for 21 years. As presiding judge of the Fifth Judicial Administrative District, he assigns judges to cases when the regular judge is unavailable.
Contact David Kassabian at 886-3778 or kassabiand@caller.com
You must follow these rules in order to post comments:
* 1. Keep it clean.Comments that are obscene, vulgar, lewd or sexually-oriented will get the ax. Creative spelling of such terms also will be banned.
* 2. Don't threaten to hurt or kill anyone.
* 3. Be truthful. Don't lie about anyone or anything.
* 4. Be nice. No racism, sexism or any other sort of -ism that degrades another person.
* 6. Keep it local. Do not post direct links to sites outside of Caller.com.
* 7. Police yourselves. Hit the "Suggest Removal" button on offensive comments.
* 8. Share what you know. Give us your eyewitness accounts, background, observations and history.
* 9. Ask questions. What more do you want to know about the story?
* 10. Stay focused. Keep on the story's topic.
* 11.Help us get it right. If you find a factual error or misspelling, email newmedia@caller.com or metrodesk@caller.com, or call 886-3697.
(173) User Comments:
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 389468 on June 6, 2008 at 5:04 a.m.
How horrible!
Was alcohol involved?
related links Posted by 240665 on June 6, 2008 at 5:27 a.m.
(This comment was removed by the site staff.)
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 232854 on June 6, 2008 at 5:57 a.m.
was he drinking, thats the first question everyone else is asked.........
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 401467 on June 6, 2008 at 6:10 a.m.
He'll probably show up for court. He loves to send people to prison for drinking.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 712045 on June 6, 2008 at 6:26 a.m.
First, prayers for the young man seriously injured. May God be with him and his family. Second, I am glad Banales was not seriously injured but I wonder if Banales was speeding or perhaps on his cell phone and not paying attention. I hope DPS does a full investigation and does not form a biased opinion based on the fact that he is a judge.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 240803 on June 6, 2008 at 6:30 a.m.
My prayers for the injured state employee and his family.
All you people care about is for the judge to be intoxicated.
I can't believe the heartless and non compassionate souls that exist in this world.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 449075 on June 6, 2008 at 6:33 a.m.
Being a judge should be secondary in this situation. He is not in control of the investigation. I hope he was not on his cell phone, maybe this is a good example of what happens when you try to multitask while driving. May God be with the injuried man and his family. A full investigation should be performed and being a judge is no excuse for failure to CONTROL you vehicle.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 412890 on June 6, 2008 at 6:35 a.m.
sounds like one of our law biding officials was carring some excess speed going into that ramp. He had to have to knock that TDOT truck the distance TV news said.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 389468 on June 6, 2008 at 6:35 a.m.
We don't know if alcohol was involved or if the Judge was preoccupied or if it was merely a bad patch of road, but it's not beyond the real of possibilities for two types of justice in Nueces County . . . Bryan Smith? Mauricio Cellis?
Let's just hope a REAL investigation takes place and that the public is informed, both these men are public servants.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 711681 on June 6, 2008 at 6:37 a.m.
I can't guess on whether or not he was drinking, but in my estimation: Judge Banales was probably speeding. In order for a mid-size car to send a much larger parked truck "approximately 50 yards" and "up an embankment" after impact, I would assume a high rate of speed. I would guess since he's on a ramp with advisory speeds (probably at 40MPH), that he was going much faster than that and that's how he also probably lost control.
I wish the report would state which ramp exactly Judge Banales was entering. There's one flyover ramp that heads towards Calallen and another ramp that heads towards Downtown. I'd like to know where the TxDOT truck was parked, and where Banales veered off the pavement.
I saw the accident yesterday when I was leaving work, and it looked horrible. The entire roof of the mid-size car was destroyed, and I was thinking that driver was seriously injured or killed.
My prayers go out to the TxDOT worker,. I hope he recovers fully. I also hope Judge Banales is doing well.
Curtis Rock
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 259150 on June 6, 2008 at 6:51 a.m.
Maybe now the Judge will know that accidents CAN happen. Hope the TxDot workers pulls out of this with no long-term effects. Because of the media attention I'm sure the Judge will be citing for "failure to control" his vehicle and/or "driver inattention".
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 240803 on June 6, 2008 at 6:59 a.m.
in response to 401467
I believe sending people to prison for drinking is Judge Banales job. If they don't get punished then it's the "judges are too soft on criminals" complaint.
Wheather he loves to send people to prison I would'nt know.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 233106 on June 6, 2008 at 7:11 a.m.
37 accidents now in the past 15 months for county employees?
Sounds reckless. Will a full investigation checking for drugs and alcohol be done?
Wasn't there a court manager a few years ago charged with a felony because of a cell phone and an accident?
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 239123 on June 6, 2008 at 7:25 a.m.
Post 233106, I believe it was because of make up. She was putting on her makeup that caused an accident.
My prayers go out to the TXDot employee. Also to Judge Banales.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 240803 on June 6, 2008 at 7:39 a.m.
Yes, accidents do happen. However when a person makes the choice to get in the drivers seat of a vehicle, while under the influence of alcohol or drugs then thats no accident.
I am sure for all of you anxiously awaiting toxicology reports on the judge, maybe you won't be disappointed. Seems some of you are wishing for the worst
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 240354 on June 6, 2008 at 7:44 a.m.
so many of you jump to conclusions on what happend. maybe you should be out there doing the investigation. Maybe he had a heart attack and lost control? you never know, but so many of you are sure that it was alcohol related. your minds are filled with so much negativity and so many people hate to live here because of you.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 246492 on June 6, 2008 at 7:46 a.m.
in response to 240354
Well said and painfully true.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 389468 on June 6, 2008 at 7:50 a.m.
We weren't the ones driving the car.
We weren't the ones who hit that poor TXDOT worker.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 245928 on June 6, 2008 at 7:52 a.m.
omg, bloggeristas !!! Posting privileges removed yesterday have been restored and here we go with speculations, such as faulty tires on the Cadillac. Sheesh, to survive after being slammed that hard and trapped that badly. God bless the TxDOT employee and Judge Banales and all the families and friends.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 699448 on June 6, 2008 at 8:06 a.m.
My prayers go out to Judge Banales AND the TXDOT worker as well as their families.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 592398 on June 6, 2008 at 8:12 a.m.
May God be with all involved. I am sure that Judge Banales and his family feel horrible. Come on folks, accidents happen and we have no idea why this one happened.
Maybe he was headed back to work, maybe this or maybe that, but lets wait until the investigation is done.
My son went to school with his daugter and I personally think Judge Banales is a awesome individual. And no I am not hispanic so don't go there. He was very involved with his kids and I think as a judge he is fair.
Keeping everyone involved in my prayers.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 699733 on June 6, 2008 at 8:16 a.m.
Some of you all are so stupid. Judge Banales is a fair judge and you all need to give him the benefit of the doubt. He could have been having trouble breathing, having a heart attack or even having a stroke. You all don't know that but you all are just assuming that he was drunk. Instead of being so narrowed minded you all should pray for the TXDOT worker and for Judge Banales as we don't know what actually happened. My prayers got out to Judge Banales and for the TXDOT worker and the families.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 233517 on June 6, 2008 at 8:17 a.m.
I like Judge Banales.
I wish this young TX Dot worker well and hopefully a full and speedy recovery.
Maybe the Judge just lost control of his car when he noticed the parked vehicle. Did anyone ever think about that? Remember, Banales is the Judge who is trying to keep your kids safe from sex offenders, so before you go bashing him without knowing the facts, remember, he is a good judge.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 263127 on June 6, 2008 at 8:18 a.m.
Surely authorities administered a breathilizer test to theJudge to allay any future questions by the public about his sobriety. There is no question that a high rate of speed was involved, and there are strict laws regarding caution in work or construction zones. The Judge clearly was the at-fault party to the accident. Judges and Law Enforcement are held to a higher standard than those they serve, so the public will expect a thorough and fair review of his case. In the meantime our wish is for a full and complete recovery by both parties. God be with them.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 238309 on June 6, 2008 at 8:20 a.m.
Time to retire; in jail, maybe?
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 712812 on June 6, 2008 at 8:26 a.m.
i hope judge banales ok. what bothers me is how the news reported the story. to me, it seems the main part of the story was all about judge banales being in a car accident. the story should focus on the fact that a person (txdot worker) was almost killed. my heart goes out to the worker's family. it seems that the judge was driving at an unsafe speed. judge banales will have to live the rest of his life knowing he almost killed someone....and that is heavy.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 237538 on June 6, 2008 at 8:28 a.m.
this is pompous judge..it is mandatory to DPS to take a blood draw if there is a death or possiblity of a death in an auto accident..
lets see fit they did.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 235683 on June 6, 2008 at 8:34 a.m.
I'm just suprised some of you even know how to turn on a computer...
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 235519 on June 6, 2008 at 8:34 a.m.
Many of the above comments indeed have merit, BUT lest we forget, Judge Banales and the gentleman clinging on to life are both sons, brothers, husbands and I know the Judge is a Father, we as fellow humans should be less critical and opiniated if we are unfamiliar with the entire situation.
Please be more considerate in comments made.
In the interim, pray for their recovery.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 700159 on June 6, 2008 at 8:37 a.m.
My prayers for the TX Dot worker and his family as well as Judge Banales. I can only imagine how he must feel. I will keep everyone affected by this in my prayers.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 245407 on June 6, 2008 at 8:49 a.m.
Judge Banales is a respected Lawyer, and Judge.
He is not immune from any investigation, HE WOULD BE THE FIRST TO REQUEST AN INVESTIGATION INTO HIS ACTIONS.
I very seriously doubt alcohol was involved, knowing the judge the way I do.
As for the Tx DOT worker, MY DEEPEST PRAYERS FOR YOUR SAFE AND FULL RECOVERY !
SOMETIMES ACCIDENTS HAPPEN, SOMETIMES BAD THINGS HAPPEN TO GOOD PEOPLE, WE SHOULD NOT BE SO QUICK TO BLAME OR LAY BLAME, OR ASSUME THE WORSE.
PRAYERS TO ALL OF THE FAMILY MEMBERS INVOLVED.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 269677 on June 6, 2008 at 8:52 a.m.
You do not hear anything about a ticket or any charges? If this was anyone other than a judge. At least failure to maintain control. But nothing.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 711504 on June 6, 2008 at 8:53 a.m.
My prayers are with both the Judge and the worker.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 241503 on June 6, 2008 at 8:54 a.m.
"A Texas Department of Transportation heavy-duty pickup with a cherry-picker lift was parked near a ramp ...The truck was some 50 yards away, pushed halfway up an embankment to another ramp by the force of impact."
COME ON! Banales must have been doing a very very high rate of speed to cause a heavy duty CHERRY PICKER truck to be PUSHED HALFWAY UP AN EMBANKMENT!
If the TxDot worker dies, Judge Banales needs to go to prison for vehicular manslaughter. He needs to at least step down and serve some jail time for what he has done so far. I sincerely hope this investigation is not muddied by politicians trying to protect him.
I don't know the man but I do want to see justice service equally with the same veracity he used while being a district court judge. I'm tired of seeing local 'politicos' get a slap on the hand for serious crimes while regular folks like us get the book thrown at us. Judge Banales had a strong reputation for throwning books.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 708377 on June 6, 2008 at 8:56 a.m.
Does anyone know if it had been raining in this area yesterday afternoon? It rained on I37 and towards Calallen yesterday afternoon, but I don't know if it rained closer to town. If it did, those ramps would have been filled with oil and extremely slick. Those ramps are death traps after just a little bit of rain. If he took that turn a little to fast he would have went out of control, which is what looks like happened. No One has said that he was drunk or that alchol was involved at all so let's let the police do their job and not speculate.
To the TXDot worker...My prayers are with you and your family! Get well soon...
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 351711 on June 6, 2008 at 8:58 a.m.
I heard that the sherrif seemed more concerned about the Judge condition then the poor Gentleman that got hit...... according to the interview they had yesterday.... I didn't see it, but heard about it from more than one person. If that is true, how sad.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 351711 on June 6, 2008 at 9:03 a.m.
Our hearts go out to the Victims and their Familys and to the Judges Family as well, hoping a speedy recovery for all.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 240926 on June 6, 2008 at 9:12 a.m.
WELL, LET'S JUST HANG THE JUDGE BY HIS THUMBS AND BEAT HIM. I CAN'T BELIEVE HOW SMALL MINDED SOME OF YOU THUGS ARE. JUST BECAUSE YOU DRIVE DRUNK AND UNDER THE INFLUENCE DOES NOT MEAN THE JUDGE WOULD. I'M SORRY THE DOT GUY GOT HIT, BUT I FEEL QUITE SURE THE JUDGE IS QUITE UPSET ABOUT IT TOO. GIVE THE JUDGE A CHANCE. YOU PEOPLE JUST LOVE TO HOPE FOR THE WORST FOR ANYONE IN AUTHORITY. HOW DOES IT FEEL TO BE PERFECT???????
related links Posted by 329691 on June 6, 2008 at 9:13 a.m.
(This comment was removed by the site staff.)
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 329691 on June 6, 2008 at 9:22 a.m.
Let's show a little more compassion for the victim in the hospital. Heaven knows how long he will be laid up as for the judge he's banged up but he'll recover, buy a new car and go to work. Will the victim recover? What about his family?
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 374265 on June 6, 2008 at 9:25 a.m.
He will probably get away with it, and in the meantime, that TxDOT worker will never be the same, if he lives.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 323020 on June 6, 2008 at 9:26 a.m.
It 's obvious that the cause was failure to control speed,but they indicate they are unable to determine the cause. He'll probably get away with losing a few hours of vacation time like the police chief.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 442726 on June 6, 2008 at 9:27 a.m.
I am a friend of the worker and his family. It seems there is so much more concern about the judge, whose injuries were not life threatening, than for the person fighting for his life in the hospital. My heart and prayers go out to my friend and his family.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 240803 on June 6, 2008 at 9:27 a.m.
in response to 351711
I've heard alot of things too, that does not make them true. We don't know about Sherrif Kaelin's concerns or feelings from what we hear.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 240593 on June 6, 2008 at 9:36 a.m.
there is so much animosity on here for judge banales.... i take it that most of you all have had a loved one or yourself, perhaps, sentenced by this judge!!!
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 231171 on June 6, 2008 at 9:39 a.m.
Prayers to all involved-it sounds like the judge is going to be ok and hopefully the TxDot worker can somehow pull through.
As for that area, like many others in this city, people drive like "bats outta hell"-so I am not surprised that this has happened and am surprised that it doesn't happen more often. CCPD, who I usually support, never seems to catch the fools who fly around the city at 95 mph in a 30 mph hour zone. Obviously, there is a reason that we don't see more officers on the streets, and that needs to be fixed.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 272666 on June 6, 2008 at 9:40 a.m.
I never heard so much bull in my life as in these comments, you and I all know there is going to be a white wash and will be made to go away its called " executive privilege"
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 592398 on June 6, 2008 at 9:41 a.m.
Please wait for the investagation to be complete. No one knows what happened, maybe there was a slick spot on the highway, maybe something had spilled out of a tanker, who knows. If he did hit a slick spot and then lost control, the speed of his car could have increased at that point.
Obviously he has angered quite a few in this town.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 712985 on June 6, 2008 at 9:45 a.m.
WHY DIDNT THEY STICK HIM WITH A NEEDLE AND DRAW BLOOD FROM HIM? THEY WOULD HAVE DONE THAT TO ANYONE ELSE.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 711235 on June 6, 2008 at 9:48 a.m.
in response to 592398
when you hit a slick spot you don't speed up, you can't slow down, but you don't accelerate fast enought to move a large truck 50 yards.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 712631 on June 6, 2008 at 9:51 a.m.
in response to 592398
i agree.. let's wait before we assume.
hope the txdot worker pulls through.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 425944 on June 6, 2008 at 9:52 a.m.
in response to 351711
How sad of you to spread gossip and rumors that are not true. Maybe you are Mr. Flores himself?
Sheriff Jim Kaelin is adamantly AGAINST drunk driving by ANYONE. He would never try to cover up anything.
He is just as concerned for the seriously injured Tx Dot worker as he is for Mr. Banales.
Nice try for you to try to discredit the Sheriff in all of this.
After all, .....it is an election year isn't it?
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 712985 on June 6, 2008 at 9:54 a.m.
in response to 592398
yea dude, what are you smokin' . if im going 30 mph and i hit a "slick spot", my car does NOT speed up. dont you know anything about physics?
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 463263 on June 6, 2008 at 9:54 a.m.
This same stuff happens to all stories posted here by CCT... Everybody assumes something in some way or another about the story, but now it's the judge involved and it's all wrong?
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 705049 on June 6, 2008 at 9:56 a.m.
I feel sorry for the worker. As far as any legal action against the judge, all the lawyers and judges in our legal systems are buddies. They act like they hate each other in court but they'll be sharing a pizza at lunch. Odds are the judge will get off easy.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 409842 on June 6, 2008 at 10:01 a.m.
prayers to the txdot worker
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 712987 on June 6, 2008 at 10:02 a.m.
in response to 351711
I thought we could not spread lies on here? What you just did is just as bad as the National Inquirer.
Two people were involved in a horrible accident. None of us know the details.
The picture of the judge's car looked scary. I am surprised he survived. As for the TXdot worker, I am hoping he is able to come out of this and have a full recovery.
Does the TXdot worker have children? If so, can you imagine what they are going through? Not only that, what about his parents or other members of his family?
What about the judge? I know he has a family. They are probably worried about both parties. The pain to see a loved one lying in a hospital bed after something traumatic may go away but it will stay with you forever.
Have some sympathy for both worker and judge. Hope for the best out of both of them.
Caller Times, do you have any more details concerning this accident? Please hurry and update before this blog is filled with gossip and rumors.
My thoughts and prayers go out to both families as they go through this.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 409842 on June 6, 2008 at 10:02 a.m.
the judge was on a panel at the federal courthouse yesterday...the discussion was to start at 4 p.m...the accident happened at 3:20...wonder if he was rushing to the panel.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 425944 on June 6, 2008 at 10:06 a.m.
in response to 409842
If the accident happened at 3:20, and he didn't have to be at the Federal Courthouse till 4.....then that would have allowed him plenty of time. (there would have been no need to rush)
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 712985 on June 6, 2008 at 10:07 a.m.
in response to 409842
yea it was 3:20, he had one hour to make it to the pow-wow.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 239123 on June 6, 2008 at 10:07 a.m.
post 329691 No it wasn't a closet thing. It was in the news. It happened maybe in the late 90s. I don't remember the name of the female. Maybe someone else remembers that accident.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 452408 on June 6, 2008 at 10:09 a.m.
First and foremost...I pray for both parties, family, and friends and for a speedy recovery for both men.
For all of you who think the book should be thrown at the Judge or that think he will get away with it just because of his standing in the community...I can almost guarantee that since the Judge probably has no prior record (he wouldn't be a Judge if he did), and if he is guilty of anything other than failure to control speed, then he will be granted probation. So all of hoping for prison keep dreaming. And that outcome would have nothing to do with his standing in the community. There was a lady on probation in San Patricio County (where I work) who has killed 3 people at two different times for drunk driving or driving under the influence of drugs and has been granted probation. Only after she tested positive for drugs was her probation revoked and sentenced to prison.
I hope none of you ever make a mistake this great. Because I don't want hear you ask "please don't send me to prison, it was the first time I ever screwed up". I hope the book gets thrown at you. It is unbelieveable how inconsiderate and rude people are. Next thing you know someone is going to assume the TxDot worker jumped in front of the Judge in order to be able to file a lawsuit.
Every single one of you on here crucifying the judge is nothing short of pathetic...and I don't even know the man.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 707647 on June 6, 2008 at 10:11 a.m.
Hope the TxDOT worker pulls thru. My prayers go out to them and their family.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 232885 on June 6, 2008 at 10:18 a.m.
Those fly-overs going both ways from SPID are accidents waiting to happen. There have been so many accidents on those exits that have resulted in serious life long injury.
You know maybe it was just an accident, maybe he was going a little fast, BUT how many of you can say that you haven't done the same thing at some point and time? I for one hope that all parties involved will pull through this.
Judge Banales is a good man and like other posters have said, he is a very good family man that believes in what he does as a judge. I am not a supporter of his wifes political position, but they are both decent folk.
Some of you people have such a blood lust and hope that the worst is true. You people frighten me more than any political officer ever could.
God Bless the Banales family and the family of the TxDOT worker
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 372756 on June 6, 2008 at 10:18 a.m.
I think the people on here writinng mean things about the judge are prolly people who have been sentenced by him or have family members who have been sentenced by him. Isn't everyone always complaining about how unfair the system is and how lax the judges are? Now you are slamming him for being too harsh? Is there no pleasing you people? Of course not, cause people love to have something to complain about. I agree with the bloggers who say maybe he did have problems breathing or was in the midst of a stroke. Also he is the one trying to keep our children safe so defintely kudos to him! As for the TXDOT worker, I sure do hope he gets better and my prayers are with him and his family.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 712987 on June 6, 2008 at 10:19 a.m.
Some people get great satisfaction of bringing others down to their own levels.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 711114 on June 6, 2008 at 10:31 a.m.
I do believe that newspapers generally have an obligation to investigate any elected official. This is particularly true when an elected Judge poses as being strict on law and order.
For example, was there any recent police report or incidents of this elected official? Or, was this official involved in any previous auto accidents in suspicious circumstances wherein someone was seriously hurt by this man?
I would very much appreciate any informative article dealing with these issues.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 712710 on June 6, 2008 at 10:38 a.m.
My prayers go out to the city employee and Judge Banales. I hope everyone involved pulls through. What a terrible accident.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 376065 on June 6, 2008 at 10:40 a.m.
Is this the judge married to Peggy Banales?? The Peggy Banales with the magic funds transfer account??? Poor TXDoT worker. This will be one more coverup to help the priviledged politico class in Corpus Christi.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 235933 on June 6, 2008 at 10:51 a.m.
All you people who speed and disregard other's safty, let this be a lesson to you. Tailgating, speeding, weaving in and out of traffic just so you can get some place faster in 2 minutes just is simply not worth it.
SLOW DOWN!!!
Now the county gets ANOTHER tic on the tally sheet for a motor vehicle accident...
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 274667 on June 6, 2008 at 10:58 a.m.
He was probably mad that the money was going toward hiway maintenance rather than building him another $130,000 office!!!
I know that sounds horrible, but hey!!! He deserves it as far as the tax payers are concerned. What goes around comes around. Unfortunatly a low paid laborer had to pay the price once again.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 712985 on June 6, 2008 at 10:58 a.m.
in response to 235933
we dont need to slow down, you need to move out of the fast lane, GET OUT OF THE WAY!!
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 274667 on June 6, 2008 at 11:08 a.m.
Let's be honost about all this.
Had the worker hit Banales as he was crossing the street at the court house, he would have been whisked off to jail immediatly. There would be NO investigation. The worker would have been brought up on charges, jailed, sentenced and hung within 48 hours. Not to mention the civil suits that would then hit him that would cost him his home, cars, job and future.
Just a thought...
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 712985 on June 6, 2008 at 11:10 a.m.
two things dont make sense to me.
#1) THE CADILLAC SLID OFF THE PAVEMENT.
#2) THE TRUCK TRAVELED 50 YRDS.
1: when was the last time you saw a car just slide off pavement?
a) in the snow
b) in the rain
neither was the case in this situation.
2: do you know how far 50 yrds is???? that id half a football field!!
the truck probably weighs twice what the caddy does with all that equipment on it.
the judge was in WAY to big a hurry.
he should be punished.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 709587 on June 6, 2008 at 11:11 a.m.
My prayers go out to that young man and his family , also to the judge, you know, i hear many talk bad about judge banales, but you know what , hes not a bad person , he is looking out for our children , and if hes hard its cause hes protecting us,and he is fair. I believe that he doesnt mean any harm hes doing his job, and this is not about his work , its about the accident and prayfully everything will be ok, God Bless to you all and your familys.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 329691 on June 6, 2008 at 11:11 a.m.
in response to 239123
Ooookay, I get! Thanks for clearing that out. It's one of those social diseases and on the bench he looks like he couldn't hurt a fly and dangerous behind the wheel, too!! He needs to go to driving classes along with the other county employees.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 342632 on June 6, 2008 at 11:15 a.m.
i just hope that the police officials do their jobs the way they should and handle this situation the way it should be handled and not any differently because of one person being a judge.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 376065 on June 6, 2008 at 11:24 a.m.
in response to 709587
The judge may very well do his job great, but I am one voter who will not forget his wife and her "funny accounting methods" for funding an overpriced remodeling of his office. It is that sense of "entitlement" that makes me angry and should anger every tax paying citizen in Nueces County.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 373365 on June 6, 2008 at 11:24 a.m.
It seems like everyone is assuming alcohol or cell phone use is at fault. Everyone apparently understands these hazards, but I constantly am avoiding collisions from people I see are using their cell phone and driving, and can only guess at the alcohol use. If we know and understand these problems, why are they so common?
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 712993 on June 6, 2008 at 11:25 a.m.
This judge is something. He hits a worker that gets paid a fraction of what he himself makes and probably will forget about it in a few days. That's the way he appears to be, constantly sentencing people with little regards to the entire situation only to build a name for himself as the meanest judge in Corpus. Why? He deserves no leniency and should have a permanent mark on his record. I don't care how you look at it, he was at fault. There is know faulty roads or misunderstood signs that I have ever seen or heard of before. Let's see who plays the corpus christi people as fools and tries to make this seem like the judge is oh so innocent. I hope that you get the same attitude and judgment that you subject the people that make mistakes get, because yea your not God and some mistakes can be learned without the harsh punishment that you put forth on the people.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 712992 on June 6, 2008 at 11:34 a.m.
Everyone's making this thing so big because of who is involved. Putting identities aside, let's not forget there is a person clinging to life through no fault of his own. And the second person who caused is in far better shape than the first.
I take that exit ramp daily, and I believe that to lose control in that area you must be going at an excessive speed or you are not capable of fully controlling your vehicle on curves. In either case, the driver is at fault for any loss of control.
The area did not receive any rain prior, so that can be ruled out. If perhaps there was a slick spot for whatever reason, the driver should be attentive and adjust accordingly. if the driver suffered some sort of episode suchas a heart attack, etc., should there not have been warning signs to cause him to pull over and call for help?
As I said I drive through there daily, and saw the accident shortly after it happened. My opinion is that the driver is at fault to some degree and if his inability to control his vehicle was caused by alcohol, or drugs, that that is just wrong.
He should be held accountable for his actions acording to the circumtances in which it all happened.
I hope the worker comes out okay. I hope the same for the driver as I believe he will be. In any case this will be something to carry on his conscience for the rest of his life.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 709587 on June 6, 2008 at 11:36 a.m.
in response to 376065
I understand your concern of his wife spending, but the whole issue is not his other half, its the accident that happened, and we just need to pray that everyone is gonna be ok, and pray for them and there families.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 712993 on June 6, 2008 at 11:45 a.m.
IN response to 709587
Give me a break, he is not trying to protect our people. He is trying to protect a certain kind of people.. That money he spent on his over priced office came at some one losing there freedoms price. I wonder who he sentenced to get his hands on the money to make his office. He is not diplomatic by any means. He is however using his wrath of punishment to strike fear in your behind to be kissing up like that.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 376065 on June 6, 2008 at 11:57 a.m.
in response to 709587
I sincerely pray that everyone gets well and resumes their life as before; I just don't want to see this driver (Judge Banales) get any preferential treatment because of his community status. Like the paper said, the Judge is not hurt badly, so why did he lose control of that 6000 pound vehicle he drives and why was he is such a hurry? Failure to control speed, for sure.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 709952 on June 6, 2008 at 12:06 p.m.
Is this the same righteous judge (judge Bananas) that makes sex offenders put signs in their front yards? Wonder what they think right now. Did you see his car after the accident? I agree with post 712985, but since he's a judge I'm sure everything is in motion to get him off the hook. I'm sure there're a lot of people willing to do him a favor right now in case they end up in his court room.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 711318 on June 6, 2008 at 12:12 p.m.
I'll probably be banned by the editor for this one, but here goes.....
The appearance of any special interest or privilege in this case is most important. From the first instant it was reported, this was not the case. Mysteriously, this website closed down comments on this article. Go ahead and write an explanation, but it's too late.Conclusion is that it was a petty attempt to abridge free speech.
The one local TV news channel that I watched last night, Channel 6, placed this story in third or fourth place, behind a home burglary, with skewed emphasis on the condition of the judge, including the skewed interview with the Sheriff. We could use some pointers from the Soviet's on this type of media manipulation, because these attempts yesterday were amatuer .
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 267132 on June 6, 2008 at 12:26 p.m.
Notice the headlines? The judge's CAR hit the transportation worker, not the Judge.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 711114 on June 6, 2008 at 12:37 p.m.
I would believe that Channel 6 would put this story third or fourth. If an ordinary citizen is accused of a crime they will try to put inflammatory, untrue and prejudicial stories about them and do everything to prevent them from getting a fair trial. Channel 6 News is like fantasy and science fiction broadcast as truth.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 330770 on June 6, 2008 at 1:08 p.m.
Isn't this the guy who's wife, Peggy Banales, just voted her husband some $$$ so that he could get a new office off the taxpayer's back. What kind of integrity are you talking about? He gets a six figure salary as District Judge plus a salary for his 5th region duties, his wife gets a nice fat salary thanks to the raise she voted for herself and then they have the gall to take money from the poor people in Annaville and Calallen. Judge Banales is NOT a fair judge. Anyone who practices law in his Court knows that he is state oriented -- Judges should perform judicial duties without bias or prejudice. A judge who manifests bias on any basis in a proceeding impairs the fairness of the proceeding and brings the judiciary into disrepute. Banales has passed judgment in Court for 21 years. Not only people who are brought before his Court but also people who don't agree with him. People in Corpus do not speak their minds for some reason. They do not or can not say what they really mean. He has the power and he knows it and I think people are afraid of him.
We must hold these Judges to a higher standard for they are the ones that sit and Judge you and me for this same kind of incident. He would not hesitate for one second to put you behind bars if the shoe were on the other foot. Why are people making excuses for him. It was an accident only because Banales CHOSE to speed, talk on his cell phone or become distracted. He didn't have a heart attack, that is some excuse someone wants us to believe. He must accept responsiblity for HIS ACTION.
I too thought Sheriff Kaelin only talked and showed concern with Banales. He did not even mention the poor injured TxDot worker. I feel the preferential treatment already starting. Who gets a visit from the Sheriff when they're involved in an accident. Do you? Sounds like a cover up already starting.
My prayers go out to the worker and his family -- you know he's a goverment employee too.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 416377 on June 6, 2008 at 1:10 p.m.
how about mrs. peggy give all that extra taxpayer's money she has put aside to fix the judge's office and now help the victim and his family through this tough time. Makes sence.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 399225 on June 6, 2008 at 1:21 p.m.
Was Jim Kaelin driving the car or was he the guy that got hit? Why do we blame the Sheriff for every incident in this county? He was not involved. Get a life. Your candidate lost.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 338518 on June 6, 2008 at 1:46 p.m.
Judge Banales would be the first to expect that the appropriate procedures be followed in the investigation. He is strict but fair and seems to strive to do the RIGHT thing in everything he does. I have so much respect for this man. He has more integrity than any of you negative bloggers could ever have. I won't give the negativity any more attention. I'm sure that he and his family are devastated over this tragic event. I am so sad for the victim and his family and have them all in my prayers and I'm willing to bet, so does the Banales family.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 449075 on June 6, 2008 at 1:56 p.m.
Banales was drunk with power. Now let us see if the law works on people that do not control their vehicle.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 248197 on June 6, 2008 at 2:04 p.m.
Notice the headlines? The judge's CAR hit the transportation worker, not the Judge.
--
Stop trying to over analyze the headline. That's probably how I would title it too and I don't even care about the Judge.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 233198 on June 6, 2008 at 2:16 p.m.
OMG: The ignorance and small minds of some of you people...you have no idea what happened and are already throwing stones at the Judge...simply because he is a Judge....thugs....pfft.....get a life.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 329691 on June 6, 2008 at 2:29 p.m.
The injured worker must be in real bad shape since he will be transferred to San Antonio according to an update. Hopefully the judge will have the decency to inquire or visit this poor man. Yeah! there is alot of concern about the judge forget about the worker who's on lifesupport. Why do they have to mention the judge's car model? Cadillac Deville/Camry/Jeep who cares what he drove, his car did the injuries. He better prepare himself for a lawsuit. Could be in his own courtroom. And those of you who are so concerned about all these negative blogs, it's called Freedom of Speech. Don't login!!
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 236373 on June 6, 2008 at 2:34 p.m.
I heard he was on his wa y to Taqueria Garibaldi to catch the before dinner special.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 248197 on June 6, 2008 at 2:44 p.m.
They always mention the types of cars in incidents like these. Don't over analyze it.
And for goodness sakes, these are not blogs, these are just comments! A blog is different.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 712998 on June 6, 2008 at 2:44 p.m.
My prayers go out to the TxDOT worker, Judge Banales, & both of their families.
Instead of thinking the worst possible outcomes, we should all pray for the best in both recoveries!
Also, we all should keep in mind accidents do happen, and knowing the Banales family, I know they all feel terrible for the accident that has occured. So out of respect, no one should express negative feelings towards the family during this time of suffering. Put yourself in his shoes, no way would this be an easy ordeal to cope with. Just think, if you were laying in a hospital bed with this accident weighing on your shoulders, you too would be looking for positive support!
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 233198 on June 6, 2008 at 2:45 p.m.
248197 haha you tell'em.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 444846 on June 6, 2008 at 2:58 p.m.
in response to 233198
Maybe, the judge was rushing home, after seeing you at your home. And thats why he was speeding. Maybe you need to get a grip.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 699733 on June 6, 2008 at 3:16 p.m.
in response to 712985
You are being very judgemental. Why don't you wait and see what the police find out in their investigation. After reading what might have happened, I think speed was the factor but we don't know for sure. Let us just wait and see and pray for both victims. I am sure the family of Judge Banales feel bad for the other victirm and his family. So, let us be nice about this and quit being so ugly about what might have happened. THIS IS WHY THEY ARE CALLED ACCIDENTS. Let us all pray that we are never in accidents.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 711114 on June 6, 2008 at 3:39 p.m.
How many "accidents" is Judge Banales entitled to be involved in before he is held accountable for his actions? I believe this is the second serious very questionable "accident" wherein someone was seriously hurt.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 704748 on June 6, 2008 at 4:35 p.m.
hummm............how interesting. I just wonder, how is this going to get covered up???
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 703769 on June 6, 2008 at 4:59 p.m.
he's a judge, trust me he will get out of this with no pain ($)
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 319029 on June 6, 2008 at 5:22 p.m.
Judge Banales, You may not remember me and I sure didn't know you outside of your "State Judge" license plates that morning on Alameda and Doddridge when you almost ran me over.
Perhaps I can help you with your memory Judge Banales, I was starting to cross the street in the direction of Bank of America from Frost Bank when you made an illegal lane change from the through traffic lane to the turn lane, then ran the red light and almost hit me while I was in the crosswalk with a "WHITE CROSSWALK" light in my favor.
You may not remember with all of this information since you sped around the corner chatting with who I assume was your wife. When I got home I told my wife the whole story of the guy with a mustache and judges license plates that almost hit me.
I didn't know who you were until I saw your car on TV with the top cut open and you being carried away on a stretcher. If I were ever approached by law enforcement or an attorney I would be more than happy to relay my "experience" with your driving "under oath."
In my brief contact with you that Saturday morning, I don't think you belong behind the wheel of a car and definitely not in a position of authority in our community. Yet you are a judge! Outrageous!
I hope there is not another cover-up that is so common with investigations in Corpus Christi. My prayers are with that TEXDOT worker.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 712731 on June 6, 2008 at 5:24 p.m.
I was on my balcony right in front of the freeway that the accident happened. The judge lost control from the lane going to Callalen. The truck was right in the middle of the 2 exits in the grass and as you all know that it is also an incline. He hit the truck and bounced away into the TXdot worker. To me it seemed like if he was driving faster than normal but I dont fully know what was happening on his end. I couldnt sleep last night after seeing that poor man get hit. My prayers go out to him and his family. The roof was only gone bc of the Jaws of Life. The whole driver side was smashed in the door almost literally fell off when they tried to open it. I think the judge was more concerned about that man bc they were talking to him than rushed to the TXdot worker. From there they attended to the worker first and almost 20 minutes later they took the judge out of his car into another stretcher.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 711762 on June 6, 2008 at 5:30 p.m.
My daughter passed the same place about 10 minutes before the accident and said the wind almost blew her car off the road. So that may may have been a cause along with speed.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 233198 on June 6, 2008 at 6:56 p.m.
I am just curious.....had he NOT been a Judge would you that are hating be hating? Would the headline had been "Factory Worker or Nurse or Secretary hit City Worker." We do not know the whole story, stop creating it! Also if you think our city is so bad that there is going to be a cover up.....then why don't you move, stop making yourself miserable....Go live in another town.
Of course, I am sure the ones hating on him prolly are not on the right side of the law anyway, otherwise, why would they hate a Judge??
You guys are making yourselves look small and ignorant. You seem to forget, there is a man in the hospital and a family who is hurting too, maybe you should be sending him wishes instead of throwing up all these possible ways the accident happend that you know nothing about, why give him more hatred to read they are already in enough pain!
The lady on the Balcony: She saw the accident and did not even spew hatred, she came across very sympathedic and fair...try taking a cue from her!
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 712918 on June 6, 2008 at 7:06 p.m.
I drive that overpass to Calallen every day and it is very tricky, especially on windy days. Most people do not observe the speed limit, those that do either get tailgated or passed up. I believe the wind could have been a factor.
Everyone should just stop with the public speculation of what happened and keep these gentlemen and their families in their prayers. Regardless of their profession, at this time they are two unfortunate human beings in need of everyone's prayers.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 713008 on June 6, 2008 at 8:47 p.m.
in response to 389468
no
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 713008 on June 6, 2008 at 8:51 p.m.
in response to 401467
he's a great judge
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 713008 on June 6, 2008 at 9:01 p.m.
in response to 240803
i agree...everyone needs to pray for both parties. Leave these people alone...focus on healing, prayer and a happy ending ...lori
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 713008 on June 6, 2008 at 9:08 p.m.
in response to 233106
yes there was a court manager under investigation but it wasn't judge banales court coordinater...and not in his court
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 713008 on June 6, 2008 at 9:22 p.m.
in response to 449075
no he wasn't and you don't know my judge banales..stay focused on prayer and healing ...quick to judge...stay focused
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 713008 on June 6, 2008 at 9:28 p.m.
in response to 712918
i agree...please pray for my judge and the other gentlemen in a positive recovery.....lori
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 237099 on June 6, 2008 at 9:40 p.m.
RE: 712918
He wasn't going towards Calallen - he was traveling on SH 358 and taking the ramp to go towards downtown. If the wind was a problem wouldn't there of been more cars being blown off the roadway-? WHY do you say everyone should STOP speculating on what happened when you yourself are doing the same.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 712918 on June 6, 2008 at 10:22 p.m.
In response to 237099:
Read post 712731 (who witnessed the accident) and 711762. I'm not speculating why don't you try to read the posts again.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 712664 on June 6, 2008 at 10:42 p.m.
in response to 274667
That argument doesn't bear any logic.....
keep the thought, raise you a clue.....
Prayers to the TXDot employee and his family.
Prayers to Judge Banales and his family.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 319029 on June 6, 2008 at 10:59 p.m.
If anyone thinks that I'm saying this because he's a judge, just remember one thing. I'm sure the banks where I was almost hit by this so-called judge have surveillance camera systems, as does the Exxon gas station on the other corner.
Some of you think judges and police chiefs should be held to the same standard as everyone else. Everyone "else" is not a judge or police chief. The low standards of Corpus Christi is what made it what it is today. It's not very pretty.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 254268 on June 7, 2008 at 2:12 a.m.
He killed someone like 20 years ago. How pompous can you be to keep killing people and still get reelected and twist arms to have your wife elected?
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 710237 on June 7, 2008 at 4:42 a.m.
in response to 235519
Well, I think there is so much anomosity towards Judge Banales and of course his wife simply because how they attend to their work and positions. The issues about her moving county funds so her husband could redecorate his new office at City Hall, for him to encourage it, and for her to negotiate with the other commissioners behind the scenes when it came to the vote is the great distractor in all of this. This is what has turned many of the citizens off and this is why, unfortunately, people look upon the Judge and his wife with distrust and disgust. It did not bring out the best in us, I guess, and so people have made their feelings known which they have every right to do so.
Had the Judge and his Commissioner wife handled the above affair differently and not felt so entitled as most citizens felt, I think there would be more compassion towards him. But, it's too late for that. It isn't always the "right way" to go about something when we feel we can control everything and see that we aren't breaking a guideline as in the case of the Judge's office. The Judge and his wife got what they wanted but look at what cost it took on them. I bet they don't feel it was worth it now but this is a lesson to be learned by all public officials.
Yes, I agree, we need to nevertheless pray for everyone. My heart really goes out to Manuel Garcia, the worker, and his family. I am sure this is one of the most horrible events in their life. I am sorry they have to experience it. I am so sorry it had to happen...I am sure the Judge and his wife wished they could control something like this as well as they controlled redecorating the Judge's office.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 709654 on June 7, 2008 at 8:08 a.m.
Uh-oh.
Clear day.
No road hazards.
No inclement weather conditions.
We've all seen the posted signs concerning "workers ahead". Ramps, and their posted signs.
BIG trucks moved 50-yards by mid-sized cars. And not only moved, but pushed up an embankment at that. PUSHED UP. That children takes some hella pushin' by a much lighter object striking a much heavier stationary object. If you think not, try finding a person about 3 x's your body-weight and striking them with enough force to move them roughly 10 feet.
Some of you would do well to consult Newton's Laws as well as bone up on such things like Force, Resistance and other saiient matters
If it were me I'd better be hoping like HELL a stroke or heart attack was something it could be pinned on because anything otherwise I'd likely be going on vacation to Hotel Huntsville.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 699936 on June 7, 2008 at 10:24 p.m.
There is a fund for the txdot workers family to help with expenses while he is in the hospital. Navy Army credit union for txdot employee Martin Garcia. thank you and god bless everyone involved in this accident.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 711760 on June 8, 2008 at 6:17 p.m.
Its sad how he will probably get away with this because of his position. And as far as everyone standing up for him and the sherriff that is just crazy. I chanllenge everyone and the MEDIA to look into a sherriff deputy with the last name of Solis getting terminated because of a vehicle accident. Why doesnt he get the same treatment. Lets see how far this gets and that will show how the system is when even media keeps quiet about some of this stuff.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 459106 on June 8, 2008 at 8:33 p.m.
Okay everyone, there are 3 possible reasons, 1. alcohol related, 2. using the cell phone and not paying attention or 3. Speeding, of which he is known to do quite often. He will not admit to speeding or using the cell phone, so people, don't expect a confession from him. There are ways to find out how fast he was going, or should I say estimate of speed, but what I heard, that is no longer revelent, that law suddenly changed the day of this accident. Mr. Banales, I have seen you at the church driving out of the parking lot like a bat out of hell quite a few times. Tell me Mr. Banales, if you did not have any alcohol in your system, good, but why would you run over this man? Were you going too fast to react and avoid him. Were you distracted by the cell phone, or were you just not paying attention? Will you admit to any of this? I think you should, because if not, that means you did it on purpose? I hope I am wrong, but it has to be one of these 3. You have gone through that route many times, you know that you have to slow down, why did'nt you? Being that you are a judge, you will get away with this, there is no doubt in my mind. I have seen it way too many times in my lifetime. You may be a law abiding citizen and a good judge, but you are human and can make mistakes just like everyone else. So be a man and tell the public the real truth, after all, is'nt that what you ask of the clients, be honest, truthful? Think about it everyone, there is no other explanation, if you have one, let all of us know. Don't get me wrong, I have nothing against the judge, but he almost killed a man because of his negligence.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 243116 on June 8, 2008 at 10:14 p.m.
As all of you may understand, accidents are just that 'Accidents'. There is a lot of speculation as to the cause of the accident. Our main focus should be on the health and welfare of those involved. As a long-time friend of Martin, I hold no ill will towards the judge. Two families were affected. In retrospect, I just wished that there was just a little more coverage on Martin Garcia as there was on Judge Banales in the beginning. I just pray that everything comes out okay for all involved.
Additionally, I don't make it my business to solicit donations but there is a fund already established for Martin as posted earlier. For those who are not fully aware, there is a long and painful road to recovery that lies ahead for him and his family. For those who can, please take a moment to donate. Thank you in advance for your prayers and compassion.
Martin Garcia Fund
c/o Navy Army Federal Credit Union
P.O. Box 81349
Corpus Christi, TX 78468-1349
God Bless Martin and his family through this difficult time.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 713037 on June 8, 2008 at 10:33 p.m.
Judge Banales gave me 60 years in prison for a crime....yes he is known to be a harsh man when it comes to the law. However, this same man after 6 years of recieving my letters and those of my wife, he reduced my sentence to 10 years. I am now with my family again. I wish for the best possible outcome for the victim and the Judge. Let us show a little compassion instead of finger pointing with upturned noses.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 415028 on June 9, 2008 at 9:06 a.m.
I can’t believe almost ALL the articles say ...the car slid off the pavement! WHAT? There was no ice? No rain? Yes, wind is horrible but…you have to speeding to cause any real damage like this. How come they are not speculating that? If it was some John Doe then they would have speculated speeding. Speed had to have played a factor and I wish the news would at least say that it might have been a factor. I really hope the investigation does not end at “the car slid” and crashed into a man and pushed a (super heavy) tractor. That would insult everyone’s intelligence. I have known the Garcia family for years and they are the sweetest family. My prayers are with them.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 709587 on June 10, 2008 at 10 a.m.
My prayers go out to both familys...Does anyone know how the young man is doing?
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 713086 on June 10, 2008 at 11:57 p.m.
My name is Josemanuel Edmundo Banales. I am the eldest son of Manuel and Peggy Banales. As a family, our thoughts and prayers are with the Garcia family and we wish Mr. Garcia a speedy recovery.
I've read the blogs and I would like to thank those of you who have prayed for my father, our family, and the Garcia family as well. We are grateful for your prayers and support.
My parents are political figures in the Corpus Christi community. I've witnessed and endured the attacks on them for 20+ years. Much of the speculation I've read is at best inaccurate and defamatory with out any basis of fact and under the veil of anonymity. I realize cannot keep any one of you from "exercising your first amendment right"; but what I can do is pray.
I will pray that you have the patience to let this investigation run its course. I will pray that you remember that Mr. Garcia and his family are suffering need our compassion. And I will pray that you will look to God and ask for peace. Many of you have never met my parents so I cannot comprehend how there could be so much hate towards them.
I pray that you realize whatever is in your hearts that causes you to direct your hate towards my parents is hurting us all. My ACTS brothers, my family and I have Mr. Garcia and his family, and the community of Corpus Christi in our prayers.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 711114 on June 12, 2008 at 9:19 a.m.
Seven calls for "prayer" are noted in Josemanuel's blog. Certainly one hopes these calls for prayer are heartfelt and not self serving hypocrycy in an effort to obscure the issues and defend his father.
However, instead of generalities by Josemanuel and repeated calls for prayer, specific denial about the allegations would greatly aid the community knowledge, including information about any prior specific automobile accidents.
I will reserve judgment of this case and all cases until he or his father responds to allegations of any other serious accidents and the facts and circumstances involving all of the accidents involving Judge Banales.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 712466 on June 12, 2008 at 9:55 a.m.
my prays to Mr. Garcia and the Judge
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 713120 on June 12, 2008 at 12:58 p.m.
Serious action should be taken. It does not matter that he is a judge. HE is a cruel, mean, uncaring, person who doesn't care if he ruins people's lives. They should have given him a breathalizer among other things to determine the accident. A innocent man is now suffering for banales' carelessness and his entire family is suffering. Is it true that something to this nature happened in August of 1990 and nothing was done about it. Just like if it was a citizen who commited the crime actions would have been taken a long time ago, the person would have been arrested and could not refuse to give blood or take a breathalizer. This really pisses me off due to the fact my husband is serving a very harsh sentence that Banales sentenced him to with no feeling at all. He has a family out here a son who needs him. Did Banales care, no!!!!!!! So we should not feel sorry for him in no form or fashion, now he should be put in the same shoes, I damn sure dont care that he is a judge, the same laws should apply to him as well. Please pray for the Garcia family and by the way Banales should man up with hiss crooked a@* and publicly apologize to the Garcia family even though it will not make adifference in Mr. Garcia's physical health. I can't beleive it the heartless judge nearly took someone's life, I mean literally, he takes lives anyway by giving people hard unnecessary sentences for cases way smaller than the crime he has commited
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 713163 on June 15, 2008 at 12:49 a.m.
in response to 713086
Jose Manuel,
I feel for your father and the TXDOT worker. I myself worked in a public position and found myself under fire for something I did not do. Like your father I know it hurts to be judged by others and presumed guilty just due to the fact public employees, judges, police etc are hated by so many people. At the same time I know that I will only go as far as God wants me and this case your father is now involved in will only go as far as God seems fit.
I think it is a great thing you did by standing by your father. I know that my son standing by me during these times I am going thru means the world to me. I will pray for your family and the hardened hearts of those who wish the worst for your father. God bless you all during these times. I have seen your father in court and always liked to listen to him. He is a very wise man and the public needs to understand we are only human. God bless Mr. Garcia and his family. as well. My heart goes out to them.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 713155 on June 22, 2008 at 10:36 p.m.
Post 713163 - Why would I feel sorry for someone who caused an accident and is practically unhurt? Why would I feel sorry for someone who does not seem to be held accountable for his actions? You say you found yourself under fire for something you did not do. Are you saying Judge Banales did not hit him?
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 713337 on June 24, 2008 at 12:41 a.m.
in response to 713086
Hi Jose Manuel Edmundo Banales,
I guess you don't really know your father otherwise you would know that he is intolerant of anyone who prays and takes religious activities seriously. You mention prayers but more than likely you use these vain and hypocritical words as a smokescreen to further your father's supposed political career. He considers people who go to church on a weekly basis to be religious zealots and ridicules them.
I hope the construction worker makes it okay but I hope justice is served for the actions your father committed...
Best Regards,
Jessie
George Gongora/Caller-Times Law enforcement officers inspect a car belonging to 105th District Court Judge J. Manuel Bañales on Thursday near the Interstate 37/Padre Island Drive interchange. Rescuers had to cut the roof and doors off the Cadillac DeVille to free Bañales, who, along with the transportation worker struck, was taken to the Christus Spohn Hospital Memorial.
A local judge's car hit a transportation department worker crouching near his truck about to fix a sign Thursday afternoon, sending the worker to the hospital in critical condition, police said.
A Texas Department of Transportation heavy-duty pickup with a cherry-picker lift was parked near a ramp connecting Padre Island Drive to southbound Interstate 37 when J. Manuel Bañales, 105th District Court judge and presiding judge of the Fifth Judicial Administrative District, entered the ramp. His gold Cadillac Deville slid off the pavement and struck the truck parked a few feet away on the grass.
Two workers had just pulled over to fix a small, directional black and yellow sign about 2:45 p.m., said police Capt. John Houston, when one worker spotted the Cadillac heading straight for the truck and jumped out of the way. Another worker, 34 years old, wasn't able to move.
"He was hit with the full force of the vehicle," Houston said. "He's injured head to toe."
That worker was rushed to Christus Spohn Hospital Memorial with life-threatening injuries. Late Thursday he was in emergency surgery and on a ventilator. Bañales' injuries are not believed to be life-threatening, police said. He was taken to the same hospital.
The ramp was closed until about 6 p.m. as Corpus Christi police and Texas Department of Public Safety troopers cataloged the accident.
Houston said officers responded to the accident just like any other of the same severity, and state troopers were called in to help re-create the accident.
It wasn't clear Thursday afternoon how fast the Cadillac was going or what caused the accident, Houston said.
The Cadillac came to rest in the wrong direction, with its roof and doors removed with the Jaws of Life. The truck was some 50 yards away, pushed halfway up an embankment to another ramp by the force of impact.
As officers combed the road and car, a yellow grate from the pickup with three orange cones and a water cooler sat a few feet away from the car's front bumper. The worker who jumped out of the way was just about to set up the cones when the car struck, a transportation department spokesman said.
Bañales has been a district judge for 21 years. As presiding judge of the Fifth Judicial Administrative District, he assigns judges to cases when the regular judge is unavailable.
Contact David Kassabian at 886-3778 or kassabiand@caller.com
You must follow these rules in order to post comments:
* 1. Keep it clean.Comments that are obscene, vulgar, lewd or sexually-oriented will get the ax. Creative spelling of such terms also will be banned.
* 2. Don't threaten to hurt or kill anyone.
* 3. Be truthful. Don't lie about anyone or anything.
* 4. Be nice. No racism, sexism or any other sort of -ism that degrades another person.
* 6. Keep it local. Do not post direct links to sites outside of Caller.com.
* 7. Police yourselves. Hit the "Suggest Removal" button on offensive comments.
* 8. Share what you know. Give us your eyewitness accounts, background, observations and history.
* 9. Ask questions. What more do you want to know about the story?
* 10. Stay focused. Keep on the story's topic.
* 11.Help us get it right. If you find a factual error or misspelling, email newmedia@caller.com or metrodesk@caller.com, or call 886-3697.
(173) User Comments:
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 389468 on June 6, 2008 at 5:04 a.m.
How horrible!
Was alcohol involved?
related links Posted by 240665 on June 6, 2008 at 5:27 a.m.
(This comment was removed by the site staff.)
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 232854 on June 6, 2008 at 5:57 a.m.
was he drinking, thats the first question everyone else is asked.........
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 401467 on June 6, 2008 at 6:10 a.m.
He'll probably show up for court. He loves to send people to prison for drinking.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 712045 on June 6, 2008 at 6:26 a.m.
First, prayers for the young man seriously injured. May God be with him and his family. Second, I am glad Banales was not seriously injured but I wonder if Banales was speeding or perhaps on his cell phone and not paying attention. I hope DPS does a full investigation and does not form a biased opinion based on the fact that he is a judge.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 240803 on June 6, 2008 at 6:30 a.m.
My prayers for the injured state employee and his family.
All you people care about is for the judge to be intoxicated.
I can't believe the heartless and non compassionate souls that exist in this world.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 449075 on June 6, 2008 at 6:33 a.m.
Being a judge should be secondary in this situation. He is not in control of the investigation. I hope he was not on his cell phone, maybe this is a good example of what happens when you try to multitask while driving. May God be with the injuried man and his family. A full investigation should be performed and being a judge is no excuse for failure to CONTROL you vehicle.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 412890 on June 6, 2008 at 6:35 a.m.
sounds like one of our law biding officials was carring some excess speed going into that ramp. He had to have to knock that TDOT truck the distance TV news said.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 389468 on June 6, 2008 at 6:35 a.m.
We don't know if alcohol was involved or if the Judge was preoccupied or if it was merely a bad patch of road, but it's not beyond the real of possibilities for two types of justice in Nueces County . . . Bryan Smith? Mauricio Cellis?
Let's just hope a REAL investigation takes place and that the public is informed, both these men are public servants.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 711681 on June 6, 2008 at 6:37 a.m.
I can't guess on whether or not he was drinking, but in my estimation: Judge Banales was probably speeding. In order for a mid-size car to send a much larger parked truck "approximately 50 yards" and "up an embankment" after impact, I would assume a high rate of speed. I would guess since he's on a ramp with advisory speeds (probably at 40MPH), that he was going much faster than that and that's how he also probably lost control.
I wish the report would state which ramp exactly Judge Banales was entering. There's one flyover ramp that heads towards Calallen and another ramp that heads towards Downtown. I'd like to know where the TxDOT truck was parked, and where Banales veered off the pavement.
I saw the accident yesterday when I was leaving work, and it looked horrible. The entire roof of the mid-size car was destroyed, and I was thinking that driver was seriously injured or killed.
My prayers go out to the TxDOT worker,. I hope he recovers fully. I also hope Judge Banales is doing well.
Curtis Rock
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 259150 on June 6, 2008 at 6:51 a.m.
Maybe now the Judge will know that accidents CAN happen. Hope the TxDot workers pulls out of this with no long-term effects. Because of the media attention I'm sure the Judge will be citing for "failure to control" his vehicle and/or "driver inattention".
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 240803 on June 6, 2008 at 6:59 a.m.
in response to 401467
I believe sending people to prison for drinking is Judge Banales job. If they don't get punished then it's the "judges are too soft on criminals" complaint.
Wheather he loves to send people to prison I would'nt know.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 233106 on June 6, 2008 at 7:11 a.m.
37 accidents now in the past 15 months for county employees?
Sounds reckless. Will a full investigation checking for drugs and alcohol be done?
Wasn't there a court manager a few years ago charged with a felony because of a cell phone and an accident?
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 239123 on June 6, 2008 at 7:25 a.m.
Post 233106, I believe it was because of make up. She was putting on her makeup that caused an accident.
My prayers go out to the TXDot employee. Also to Judge Banales.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 240803 on June 6, 2008 at 7:39 a.m.
Yes, accidents do happen. However when a person makes the choice to get in the drivers seat of a vehicle, while under the influence of alcohol or drugs then thats no accident.
I am sure for all of you anxiously awaiting toxicology reports on the judge, maybe you won't be disappointed. Seems some of you are wishing for the worst
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 240354 on June 6, 2008 at 7:44 a.m.
so many of you jump to conclusions on what happend. maybe you should be out there doing the investigation. Maybe he had a heart attack and lost control? you never know, but so many of you are sure that it was alcohol related. your minds are filled with so much negativity and so many people hate to live here because of you.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 246492 on June 6, 2008 at 7:46 a.m.
in response to 240354
Well said and painfully true.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 389468 on June 6, 2008 at 7:50 a.m.
We weren't the ones driving the car.
We weren't the ones who hit that poor TXDOT worker.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 245928 on June 6, 2008 at 7:52 a.m.
omg, bloggeristas !!! Posting privileges removed yesterday have been restored and here we go with speculations, such as faulty tires on the Cadillac. Sheesh, to survive after being slammed that hard and trapped that badly. God bless the TxDOT employee and Judge Banales and all the families and friends.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 699448 on June 6, 2008 at 8:06 a.m.
My prayers go out to Judge Banales AND the TXDOT worker as well as their families.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 592398 on June 6, 2008 at 8:12 a.m.
May God be with all involved. I am sure that Judge Banales and his family feel horrible. Come on folks, accidents happen and we have no idea why this one happened.
Maybe he was headed back to work, maybe this or maybe that, but lets wait until the investigation is done.
My son went to school with his daugter and I personally think Judge Banales is a awesome individual. And no I am not hispanic so don't go there. He was very involved with his kids and I think as a judge he is fair.
Keeping everyone involved in my prayers.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 699733 on June 6, 2008 at 8:16 a.m.
Some of you all are so stupid. Judge Banales is a fair judge and you all need to give him the benefit of the doubt. He could have been having trouble breathing, having a heart attack or even having a stroke. You all don't know that but you all are just assuming that he was drunk. Instead of being so narrowed minded you all should pray for the TXDOT worker and for Judge Banales as we don't know what actually happened. My prayers got out to Judge Banales and for the TXDOT worker and the families.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 233517 on June 6, 2008 at 8:17 a.m.
I like Judge Banales.
I wish this young TX Dot worker well and hopefully a full and speedy recovery.
Maybe the Judge just lost control of his car when he noticed the parked vehicle. Did anyone ever think about that? Remember, Banales is the Judge who is trying to keep your kids safe from sex offenders, so before you go bashing him without knowing the facts, remember, he is a good judge.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 263127 on June 6, 2008 at 8:18 a.m.
Surely authorities administered a breathilizer test to theJudge to allay any future questions by the public about his sobriety. There is no question that a high rate of speed was involved, and there are strict laws regarding caution in work or construction zones. The Judge clearly was the at-fault party to the accident. Judges and Law Enforcement are held to a higher standard than those they serve, so the public will expect a thorough and fair review of his case. In the meantime our wish is for a full and complete recovery by both parties. God be with them.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 238309 on June 6, 2008 at 8:20 a.m.
Time to retire; in jail, maybe?
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 712812 on June 6, 2008 at 8:26 a.m.
i hope judge banales ok. what bothers me is how the news reported the story. to me, it seems the main part of the story was all about judge banales being in a car accident. the story should focus on the fact that a person (txdot worker) was almost killed. my heart goes out to the worker's family. it seems that the judge was driving at an unsafe speed. judge banales will have to live the rest of his life knowing he almost killed someone....and that is heavy.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 237538 on June 6, 2008 at 8:28 a.m.
this is pompous judge..it is mandatory to DPS to take a blood draw if there is a death or possiblity of a death in an auto accident..
lets see fit they did.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 235683 on June 6, 2008 at 8:34 a.m.
I'm just suprised some of you even know how to turn on a computer...
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 235519 on June 6, 2008 at 8:34 a.m.
Many of the above comments indeed have merit, BUT lest we forget, Judge Banales and the gentleman clinging on to life are both sons, brothers, husbands and I know the Judge is a Father, we as fellow humans should be less critical and opiniated if we are unfamiliar with the entire situation.
Please be more considerate in comments made.
In the interim, pray for their recovery.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 700159 on June 6, 2008 at 8:37 a.m.
My prayers for the TX Dot worker and his family as well as Judge Banales. I can only imagine how he must feel. I will keep everyone affected by this in my prayers.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 245407 on June 6, 2008 at 8:49 a.m.
Judge Banales is a respected Lawyer, and Judge.
He is not immune from any investigation, HE WOULD BE THE FIRST TO REQUEST AN INVESTIGATION INTO HIS ACTIONS.
I very seriously doubt alcohol was involved, knowing the judge the way I do.
As for the Tx DOT worker, MY DEEPEST PRAYERS FOR YOUR SAFE AND FULL RECOVERY !
SOMETIMES ACCIDENTS HAPPEN, SOMETIMES BAD THINGS HAPPEN TO GOOD PEOPLE, WE SHOULD NOT BE SO QUICK TO BLAME OR LAY BLAME, OR ASSUME THE WORSE.
PRAYERS TO ALL OF THE FAMILY MEMBERS INVOLVED.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 269677 on June 6, 2008 at 8:52 a.m.
You do not hear anything about a ticket or any charges? If this was anyone other than a judge. At least failure to maintain control. But nothing.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 711504 on June 6, 2008 at 8:53 a.m.
My prayers are with both the Judge and the worker.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 241503 on June 6, 2008 at 8:54 a.m.
"A Texas Department of Transportation heavy-duty pickup with a cherry-picker lift was parked near a ramp ...The truck was some 50 yards away, pushed halfway up an embankment to another ramp by the force of impact."
COME ON! Banales must have been doing a very very high rate of speed to cause a heavy duty CHERRY PICKER truck to be PUSHED HALFWAY UP AN EMBANKMENT!
If the TxDot worker dies, Judge Banales needs to go to prison for vehicular manslaughter. He needs to at least step down and serve some jail time for what he has done so far. I sincerely hope this investigation is not muddied by politicians trying to protect him.
I don't know the man but I do want to see justice service equally with the same veracity he used while being a district court judge. I'm tired of seeing local 'politicos' get a slap on the hand for serious crimes while regular folks like us get the book thrown at us. Judge Banales had a strong reputation for throwning books.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 708377 on June 6, 2008 at 8:56 a.m.
Does anyone know if it had been raining in this area yesterday afternoon? It rained on I37 and towards Calallen yesterday afternoon, but I don't know if it rained closer to town. If it did, those ramps would have been filled with oil and extremely slick. Those ramps are death traps after just a little bit of rain. If he took that turn a little to fast he would have went out of control, which is what looks like happened. No One has said that he was drunk or that alchol was involved at all so let's let the police do their job and not speculate.
To the TXDot worker...My prayers are with you and your family! Get well soon...
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 351711 on June 6, 2008 at 8:58 a.m.
I heard that the sherrif seemed more concerned about the Judge condition then the poor Gentleman that got hit...... according to the interview they had yesterday.... I didn't see it, but heard about it from more than one person. If that is true, how sad.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 351711 on June 6, 2008 at 9:03 a.m.
Our hearts go out to the Victims and their Familys and to the Judges Family as well, hoping a speedy recovery for all.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 240926 on June 6, 2008 at 9:12 a.m.
WELL, LET'S JUST HANG THE JUDGE BY HIS THUMBS AND BEAT HIM. I CAN'T BELIEVE HOW SMALL MINDED SOME OF YOU THUGS ARE. JUST BECAUSE YOU DRIVE DRUNK AND UNDER THE INFLUENCE DOES NOT MEAN THE JUDGE WOULD. I'M SORRY THE DOT GUY GOT HIT, BUT I FEEL QUITE SURE THE JUDGE IS QUITE UPSET ABOUT IT TOO. GIVE THE JUDGE A CHANCE. YOU PEOPLE JUST LOVE TO HOPE FOR THE WORST FOR ANYONE IN AUTHORITY. HOW DOES IT FEEL TO BE PERFECT???????
related links Posted by 329691 on June 6, 2008 at 9:13 a.m.
(This comment was removed by the site staff.)
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 329691 on June 6, 2008 at 9:22 a.m.
Let's show a little more compassion for the victim in the hospital. Heaven knows how long he will be laid up as for the judge he's banged up but he'll recover, buy a new car and go to work. Will the victim recover? What about his family?
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 374265 on June 6, 2008 at 9:25 a.m.
He will probably get away with it, and in the meantime, that TxDOT worker will never be the same, if he lives.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 323020 on June 6, 2008 at 9:26 a.m.
It 's obvious that the cause was failure to control speed,but they indicate they are unable to determine the cause. He'll probably get away with losing a few hours of vacation time like the police chief.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 442726 on June 6, 2008 at 9:27 a.m.
I am a friend of the worker and his family. It seems there is so much more concern about the judge, whose injuries were not life threatening, than for the person fighting for his life in the hospital. My heart and prayers go out to my friend and his family.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 240803 on June 6, 2008 at 9:27 a.m.
in response to 351711
I've heard alot of things too, that does not make them true. We don't know about Sherrif Kaelin's concerns or feelings from what we hear.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 240593 on June 6, 2008 at 9:36 a.m.
there is so much animosity on here for judge banales.... i take it that most of you all have had a loved one or yourself, perhaps, sentenced by this judge!!!
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 231171 on June 6, 2008 at 9:39 a.m.
Prayers to all involved-it sounds like the judge is going to be ok and hopefully the TxDot worker can somehow pull through.
As for that area, like many others in this city, people drive like "bats outta hell"-so I am not surprised that this has happened and am surprised that it doesn't happen more often. CCPD, who I usually support, never seems to catch the fools who fly around the city at 95 mph in a 30 mph hour zone. Obviously, there is a reason that we don't see more officers on the streets, and that needs to be fixed.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 272666 on June 6, 2008 at 9:40 a.m.
I never heard so much bull in my life as in these comments, you and I all know there is going to be a white wash and will be made to go away its called " executive privilege"
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 592398 on June 6, 2008 at 9:41 a.m.
Please wait for the investagation to be complete. No one knows what happened, maybe there was a slick spot on the highway, maybe something had spilled out of a tanker, who knows. If he did hit a slick spot and then lost control, the speed of his car could have increased at that point.
Obviously he has angered quite a few in this town.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 712985 on June 6, 2008 at 9:45 a.m.
WHY DIDNT THEY STICK HIM WITH A NEEDLE AND DRAW BLOOD FROM HIM? THEY WOULD HAVE DONE THAT TO ANYONE ELSE.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 711235 on June 6, 2008 at 9:48 a.m.
in response to 592398
when you hit a slick spot you don't speed up, you can't slow down, but you don't accelerate fast enought to move a large truck 50 yards.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 712631 on June 6, 2008 at 9:51 a.m.
in response to 592398
i agree.. let's wait before we assume.
hope the txdot worker pulls through.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 425944 on June 6, 2008 at 9:52 a.m.
in response to 351711
How sad of you to spread gossip and rumors that are not true. Maybe you are Mr. Flores himself?
Sheriff Jim Kaelin is adamantly AGAINST drunk driving by ANYONE. He would never try to cover up anything.
He is just as concerned for the seriously injured Tx Dot worker as he is for Mr. Banales.
Nice try for you to try to discredit the Sheriff in all of this.
After all, .....it is an election year isn't it?
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 712985 on June 6, 2008 at 9:54 a.m.
in response to 592398
yea dude, what are you smokin' . if im going 30 mph and i hit a "slick spot", my car does NOT speed up. dont you know anything about physics?
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 463263 on June 6, 2008 at 9:54 a.m.
This same stuff happens to all stories posted here by CCT... Everybody assumes something in some way or another about the story, but now it's the judge involved and it's all wrong?
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 705049 on June 6, 2008 at 9:56 a.m.
I feel sorry for the worker. As far as any legal action against the judge, all the lawyers and judges in our legal systems are buddies. They act like they hate each other in court but they'll be sharing a pizza at lunch. Odds are the judge will get off easy.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 409842 on June 6, 2008 at 10:01 a.m.
prayers to the txdot worker
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 712987 on June 6, 2008 at 10:02 a.m.
in response to 351711
I thought we could not spread lies on here? What you just did is just as bad as the National Inquirer.
Two people were involved in a horrible accident. None of us know the details.
The picture of the judge's car looked scary. I am surprised he survived. As for the TXdot worker, I am hoping he is able to come out of this and have a full recovery.
Does the TXdot worker have children? If so, can you imagine what they are going through? Not only that, what about his parents or other members of his family?
What about the judge? I know he has a family. They are probably worried about both parties. The pain to see a loved one lying in a hospital bed after something traumatic may go away but it will stay with you forever.
Have some sympathy for both worker and judge. Hope for the best out of both of them.
Caller Times, do you have any more details concerning this accident? Please hurry and update before this blog is filled with gossip and rumors.
My thoughts and prayers go out to both families as they go through this.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 409842 on June 6, 2008 at 10:02 a.m.
the judge was on a panel at the federal courthouse yesterday...the discussion was to start at 4 p.m...the accident happened at 3:20...wonder if he was rushing to the panel.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 425944 on June 6, 2008 at 10:06 a.m.
in response to 409842
If the accident happened at 3:20, and he didn't have to be at the Federal Courthouse till 4.....then that would have allowed him plenty of time. (there would have been no need to rush)
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 712985 on June 6, 2008 at 10:07 a.m.
in response to 409842
yea it was 3:20, he had one hour to make it to the pow-wow.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 239123 on June 6, 2008 at 10:07 a.m.
post 329691 No it wasn't a closet thing. It was in the news. It happened maybe in the late 90s. I don't remember the name of the female. Maybe someone else remembers that accident.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 452408 on June 6, 2008 at 10:09 a.m.
First and foremost...I pray for both parties, family, and friends and for a speedy recovery for both men.
For all of you who think the book should be thrown at the Judge or that think he will get away with it just because of his standing in the community...I can almost guarantee that since the Judge probably has no prior record (he wouldn't be a Judge if he did), and if he is guilty of anything other than failure to control speed, then he will be granted probation. So all of hoping for prison keep dreaming. And that outcome would have nothing to do with his standing in the community. There was a lady on probation in San Patricio County (where I work) who has killed 3 people at two different times for drunk driving or driving under the influence of drugs and has been granted probation. Only after she tested positive for drugs was her probation revoked and sentenced to prison.
I hope none of you ever make a mistake this great. Because I don't want hear you ask "please don't send me to prison, it was the first time I ever screwed up". I hope the book gets thrown at you. It is unbelieveable how inconsiderate and rude people are. Next thing you know someone is going to assume the TxDot worker jumped in front of the Judge in order to be able to file a lawsuit.
Every single one of you on here crucifying the judge is nothing short of pathetic...and I don't even know the man.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 707647 on June 6, 2008 at 10:11 a.m.
Hope the TxDOT worker pulls thru. My prayers go out to them and their family.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 232885 on June 6, 2008 at 10:18 a.m.
Those fly-overs going both ways from SPID are accidents waiting to happen. There have been so many accidents on those exits that have resulted in serious life long injury.
You know maybe it was just an accident, maybe he was going a little fast, BUT how many of you can say that you haven't done the same thing at some point and time? I for one hope that all parties involved will pull through this.
Judge Banales is a good man and like other posters have said, he is a very good family man that believes in what he does as a judge. I am not a supporter of his wifes political position, but they are both decent folk.
Some of you people have such a blood lust and hope that the worst is true. You people frighten me more than any political officer ever could.
God Bless the Banales family and the family of the TxDOT worker
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 372756 on June 6, 2008 at 10:18 a.m.
I think the people on here writinng mean things about the judge are prolly people who have been sentenced by him or have family members who have been sentenced by him. Isn't everyone always complaining about how unfair the system is and how lax the judges are? Now you are slamming him for being too harsh? Is there no pleasing you people? Of course not, cause people love to have something to complain about. I agree with the bloggers who say maybe he did have problems breathing or was in the midst of a stroke. Also he is the one trying to keep our children safe so defintely kudos to him! As for the TXDOT worker, I sure do hope he gets better and my prayers are with him and his family.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 712987 on June 6, 2008 at 10:19 a.m.
Some people get great satisfaction of bringing others down to their own levels.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 711114 on June 6, 2008 at 10:31 a.m.
I do believe that newspapers generally have an obligation to investigate any elected official. This is particularly true when an elected Judge poses as being strict on law and order.
For example, was there any recent police report or incidents of this elected official? Or, was this official involved in any previous auto accidents in suspicious circumstances wherein someone was seriously hurt by this man?
I would very much appreciate any informative article dealing with these issues.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 712710 on June 6, 2008 at 10:38 a.m.
My prayers go out to the city employee and Judge Banales. I hope everyone involved pulls through. What a terrible accident.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 376065 on June 6, 2008 at 10:40 a.m.
Is this the judge married to Peggy Banales?? The Peggy Banales with the magic funds transfer account??? Poor TXDoT worker. This will be one more coverup to help the priviledged politico class in Corpus Christi.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 235933 on June 6, 2008 at 10:51 a.m.
All you people who speed and disregard other's safty, let this be a lesson to you. Tailgating, speeding, weaving in and out of traffic just so you can get some place faster in 2 minutes just is simply not worth it.
SLOW DOWN!!!
Now the county gets ANOTHER tic on the tally sheet for a motor vehicle accident...
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 274667 on June 6, 2008 at 10:58 a.m.
He was probably mad that the money was going toward hiway maintenance rather than building him another $130,000 office!!!
I know that sounds horrible, but hey!!! He deserves it as far as the tax payers are concerned. What goes around comes around. Unfortunatly a low paid laborer had to pay the price once again.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 712985 on June 6, 2008 at 10:58 a.m.
in response to 235933
we dont need to slow down, you need to move out of the fast lane, GET OUT OF THE WAY!!
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 274667 on June 6, 2008 at 11:08 a.m.
Let's be honost about all this.
Had the worker hit Banales as he was crossing the street at the court house, he would have been whisked off to jail immediatly. There would be NO investigation. The worker would have been brought up on charges, jailed, sentenced and hung within 48 hours. Not to mention the civil suits that would then hit him that would cost him his home, cars, job and future.
Just a thought...
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 712985 on June 6, 2008 at 11:10 a.m.
two things dont make sense to me.
#1) THE CADILLAC SLID OFF THE PAVEMENT.
#2) THE TRUCK TRAVELED 50 YRDS.
1: when was the last time you saw a car just slide off pavement?
a) in the snow
b) in the rain
neither was the case in this situation.
2: do you know how far 50 yrds is???? that id half a football field!!
the truck probably weighs twice what the caddy does with all that equipment on it.
the judge was in WAY to big a hurry.
he should be punished.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 709587 on June 6, 2008 at 11:11 a.m.
My prayers go out to that young man and his family , also to the judge, you know, i hear many talk bad about judge banales, but you know what , hes not a bad person , he is looking out for our children , and if hes hard its cause hes protecting us,and he is fair. I believe that he doesnt mean any harm hes doing his job, and this is not about his work , its about the accident and prayfully everything will be ok, God Bless to you all and your familys.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 329691 on June 6, 2008 at 11:11 a.m.
in response to 239123
Ooookay, I get! Thanks for clearing that out. It's one of those social diseases and on the bench he looks like he couldn't hurt a fly and dangerous behind the wheel, too!! He needs to go to driving classes along with the other county employees.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 342632 on June 6, 2008 at 11:15 a.m.
i just hope that the police officials do their jobs the way they should and handle this situation the way it should be handled and not any differently because of one person being a judge.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 376065 on June 6, 2008 at 11:24 a.m.
in response to 709587
The judge may very well do his job great, but I am one voter who will not forget his wife and her "funny accounting methods" for funding an overpriced remodeling of his office. It is that sense of "entitlement" that makes me angry and should anger every tax paying citizen in Nueces County.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 373365 on June 6, 2008 at 11:24 a.m.
It seems like everyone is assuming alcohol or cell phone use is at fault. Everyone apparently understands these hazards, but I constantly am avoiding collisions from people I see are using their cell phone and driving, and can only guess at the alcohol use. If we know and understand these problems, why are they so common?
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 712993 on June 6, 2008 at 11:25 a.m.
This judge is something. He hits a worker that gets paid a fraction of what he himself makes and probably will forget about it in a few days. That's the way he appears to be, constantly sentencing people with little regards to the entire situation only to build a name for himself as the meanest judge in Corpus. Why? He deserves no leniency and should have a permanent mark on his record. I don't care how you look at it, he was at fault. There is know faulty roads or misunderstood signs that I have ever seen or heard of before. Let's see who plays the corpus christi people as fools and tries to make this seem like the judge is oh so innocent. I hope that you get the same attitude and judgment that you subject the people that make mistakes get, because yea your not God and some mistakes can be learned without the harsh punishment that you put forth on the people.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 712992 on June 6, 2008 at 11:34 a.m.
Everyone's making this thing so big because of who is involved. Putting identities aside, let's not forget there is a person clinging to life through no fault of his own. And the second person who caused is in far better shape than the first.
I take that exit ramp daily, and I believe that to lose control in that area you must be going at an excessive speed or you are not capable of fully controlling your vehicle on curves. In either case, the driver is at fault for any loss of control.
The area did not receive any rain prior, so that can be ruled out. If perhaps there was a slick spot for whatever reason, the driver should be attentive and adjust accordingly. if the driver suffered some sort of episode suchas a heart attack, etc., should there not have been warning signs to cause him to pull over and call for help?
As I said I drive through there daily, and saw the accident shortly after it happened. My opinion is that the driver is at fault to some degree and if his inability to control his vehicle was caused by alcohol, or drugs, that that is just wrong.
He should be held accountable for his actions acording to the circumtances in which it all happened.
I hope the worker comes out okay. I hope the same for the driver as I believe he will be. In any case this will be something to carry on his conscience for the rest of his life.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 709587 on June 6, 2008 at 11:36 a.m.
in response to 376065
I understand your concern of his wife spending, but the whole issue is not his other half, its the accident that happened, and we just need to pray that everyone is gonna be ok, and pray for them and there families.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 712993 on June 6, 2008 at 11:45 a.m.
IN response to 709587
Give me a break, he is not trying to protect our people. He is trying to protect a certain kind of people.. That money he spent on his over priced office came at some one losing there freedoms price. I wonder who he sentenced to get his hands on the money to make his office. He is not diplomatic by any means. He is however using his wrath of punishment to strike fear in your behind to be kissing up like that.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 376065 on June 6, 2008 at 11:57 a.m.
in response to 709587
I sincerely pray that everyone gets well and resumes their life as before; I just don't want to see this driver (Judge Banales) get any preferential treatment because of his community status. Like the paper said, the Judge is not hurt badly, so why did he lose control of that 6000 pound vehicle he drives and why was he is such a hurry? Failure to control speed, for sure.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 709952 on June 6, 2008 at 12:06 p.m.
Is this the same righteous judge (judge Bananas) that makes sex offenders put signs in their front yards? Wonder what they think right now. Did you see his car after the accident? I agree with post 712985, but since he's a judge I'm sure everything is in motion to get him off the hook. I'm sure there're a lot of people willing to do him a favor right now in case they end up in his court room.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 711318 on June 6, 2008 at 12:12 p.m.
I'll probably be banned by the editor for this one, but here goes.....
The appearance of any special interest or privilege in this case is most important. From the first instant it was reported, this was not the case. Mysteriously, this website closed down comments on this article. Go ahead and write an explanation, but it's too late.Conclusion is that it was a petty attempt to abridge free speech.
The one local TV news channel that I watched last night, Channel 6, placed this story in third or fourth place, behind a home burglary, with skewed emphasis on the condition of the judge, including the skewed interview with the Sheriff. We could use some pointers from the Soviet's on this type of media manipulation, because these attempts yesterday were amatuer .
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 267132 on June 6, 2008 at 12:26 p.m.
Notice the headlines? The judge's CAR hit the transportation worker, not the Judge.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 711114 on June 6, 2008 at 12:37 p.m.
I would believe that Channel 6 would put this story third or fourth. If an ordinary citizen is accused of a crime they will try to put inflammatory, untrue and prejudicial stories about them and do everything to prevent them from getting a fair trial. Channel 6 News is like fantasy and science fiction broadcast as truth.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 330770 on June 6, 2008 at 1:08 p.m.
Isn't this the guy who's wife, Peggy Banales, just voted her husband some $$$ so that he could get a new office off the taxpayer's back. What kind of integrity are you talking about? He gets a six figure salary as District Judge plus a salary for his 5th region duties, his wife gets a nice fat salary thanks to the raise she voted for herself and then they have the gall to take money from the poor people in Annaville and Calallen. Judge Banales is NOT a fair judge. Anyone who practices law in his Court knows that he is state oriented -- Judges should perform judicial duties without bias or prejudice. A judge who manifests bias on any basis in a proceeding impairs the fairness of the proceeding and brings the judiciary into disrepute. Banales has passed judgment in Court for 21 years. Not only people who are brought before his Court but also people who don't agree with him. People in Corpus do not speak their minds for some reason. They do not or can not say what they really mean. He has the power and he knows it and I think people are afraid of him.
We must hold these Judges to a higher standard for they are the ones that sit and Judge you and me for this same kind of incident. He would not hesitate for one second to put you behind bars if the shoe were on the other foot. Why are people making excuses for him. It was an accident only because Banales CHOSE to speed, talk on his cell phone or become distracted. He didn't have a heart attack, that is some excuse someone wants us to believe. He must accept responsiblity for HIS ACTION.
I too thought Sheriff Kaelin only talked and showed concern with Banales. He did not even mention the poor injured TxDot worker. I feel the preferential treatment already starting. Who gets a visit from the Sheriff when they're involved in an accident. Do you? Sounds like a cover up already starting.
My prayers go out to the worker and his family -- you know he's a goverment employee too.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 416377 on June 6, 2008 at 1:10 p.m.
how about mrs. peggy give all that extra taxpayer's money she has put aside to fix the judge's office and now help the victim and his family through this tough time. Makes sence.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 399225 on June 6, 2008 at 1:21 p.m.
Was Jim Kaelin driving the car or was he the guy that got hit? Why do we blame the Sheriff for every incident in this county? He was not involved. Get a life. Your candidate lost.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 338518 on June 6, 2008 at 1:46 p.m.
Judge Banales would be the first to expect that the appropriate procedures be followed in the investigation. He is strict but fair and seems to strive to do the RIGHT thing in everything he does. I have so much respect for this man. He has more integrity than any of you negative bloggers could ever have. I won't give the negativity any more attention. I'm sure that he and his family are devastated over this tragic event. I am so sad for the victim and his family and have them all in my prayers and I'm willing to bet, so does the Banales family.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 449075 on June 6, 2008 at 1:56 p.m.
Banales was drunk with power. Now let us see if the law works on people that do not control their vehicle.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 248197 on June 6, 2008 at 2:04 p.m.
Notice the headlines? The judge's CAR hit the transportation worker, not the Judge.
--
Stop trying to over analyze the headline. That's probably how I would title it too and I don't even care about the Judge.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 233198 on June 6, 2008 at 2:16 p.m.
OMG: The ignorance and small minds of some of you people...you have no idea what happened and are already throwing stones at the Judge...simply because he is a Judge....thugs....pfft.....get a life.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 329691 on June 6, 2008 at 2:29 p.m.
The injured worker must be in real bad shape since he will be transferred to San Antonio according to an update. Hopefully the judge will have the decency to inquire or visit this poor man. Yeah! there is alot of concern about the judge forget about the worker who's on lifesupport. Why do they have to mention the judge's car model? Cadillac Deville/Camry/Jeep who cares what he drove, his car did the injuries. He better prepare himself for a lawsuit. Could be in his own courtroom. And those of you who are so concerned about all these negative blogs, it's called Freedom of Speech. Don't login!!
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 236373 on June 6, 2008 at 2:34 p.m.
I heard he was on his wa y to Taqueria Garibaldi to catch the before dinner special.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 248197 on June 6, 2008 at 2:44 p.m.
They always mention the types of cars in incidents like these. Don't over analyze it.
And for goodness sakes, these are not blogs, these are just comments! A blog is different.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 712998 on June 6, 2008 at 2:44 p.m.
My prayers go out to the TxDOT worker, Judge Banales, & both of their families.
Instead of thinking the worst possible outcomes, we should all pray for the best in both recoveries!
Also, we all should keep in mind accidents do happen, and knowing the Banales family, I know they all feel terrible for the accident that has occured. So out of respect, no one should express negative feelings towards the family during this time of suffering. Put yourself in his shoes, no way would this be an easy ordeal to cope with. Just think, if you were laying in a hospital bed with this accident weighing on your shoulders, you too would be looking for positive support!
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 233198 on June 6, 2008 at 2:45 p.m.
248197 haha you tell'em.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 444846 on June 6, 2008 at 2:58 p.m.
in response to 233198
Maybe, the judge was rushing home, after seeing you at your home. And thats why he was speeding. Maybe you need to get a grip.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 699733 on June 6, 2008 at 3:16 p.m.
in response to 712985
You are being very judgemental. Why don't you wait and see what the police find out in their investigation. After reading what might have happened, I think speed was the factor but we don't know for sure. Let us just wait and see and pray for both victims. I am sure the family of Judge Banales feel bad for the other victirm and his family. So, let us be nice about this and quit being so ugly about what might have happened. THIS IS WHY THEY ARE CALLED ACCIDENTS. Let us all pray that we are never in accidents.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 711114 on June 6, 2008 at 3:39 p.m.
How many "accidents" is Judge Banales entitled to be involved in before he is held accountable for his actions? I believe this is the second serious very questionable "accident" wherein someone was seriously hurt.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 704748 on June 6, 2008 at 4:35 p.m.
hummm............how interesting. I just wonder, how is this going to get covered up???
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 703769 on June 6, 2008 at 4:59 p.m.
he's a judge, trust me he will get out of this with no pain ($)
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 319029 on June 6, 2008 at 5:22 p.m.
Judge Banales, You may not remember me and I sure didn't know you outside of your "State Judge" license plates that morning on Alameda and Doddridge when you almost ran me over.
Perhaps I can help you with your memory Judge Banales, I was starting to cross the street in the direction of Bank of America from Frost Bank when you made an illegal lane change from the through traffic lane to the turn lane, then ran the red light and almost hit me while I was in the crosswalk with a "WHITE CROSSWALK" light in my favor.
You may not remember with all of this information since you sped around the corner chatting with who I assume was your wife. When I got home I told my wife the whole story of the guy with a mustache and judges license plates that almost hit me.
I didn't know who you were until I saw your car on TV with the top cut open and you being carried away on a stretcher. If I were ever approached by law enforcement or an attorney I would be more than happy to relay my "experience" with your driving "under oath."
In my brief contact with you that Saturday morning, I don't think you belong behind the wheel of a car and definitely not in a position of authority in our community. Yet you are a judge! Outrageous!
I hope there is not another cover-up that is so common with investigations in Corpus Christi. My prayers are with that TEXDOT worker.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 712731 on June 6, 2008 at 5:24 p.m.
I was on my balcony right in front of the freeway that the accident happened. The judge lost control from the lane going to Callalen. The truck was right in the middle of the 2 exits in the grass and as you all know that it is also an incline. He hit the truck and bounced away into the TXdot worker. To me it seemed like if he was driving faster than normal but I dont fully know what was happening on his end. I couldnt sleep last night after seeing that poor man get hit. My prayers go out to him and his family. The roof was only gone bc of the Jaws of Life. The whole driver side was smashed in the door almost literally fell off when they tried to open it. I think the judge was more concerned about that man bc they were talking to him than rushed to the TXdot worker. From there they attended to the worker first and almost 20 minutes later they took the judge out of his car into another stretcher.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 711762 on June 6, 2008 at 5:30 p.m.
My daughter passed the same place about 10 minutes before the accident and said the wind almost blew her car off the road. So that may may have been a cause along with speed.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 233198 on June 6, 2008 at 6:56 p.m.
I am just curious.....had he NOT been a Judge would you that are hating be hating? Would the headline had been "Factory Worker or Nurse or Secretary hit City Worker." We do not know the whole story, stop creating it! Also if you think our city is so bad that there is going to be a cover up.....then why don't you move, stop making yourself miserable....Go live in another town.
Of course, I am sure the ones hating on him prolly are not on the right side of the law anyway, otherwise, why would they hate a Judge??
You guys are making yourselves look small and ignorant. You seem to forget, there is a man in the hospital and a family who is hurting too, maybe you should be sending him wishes instead of throwing up all these possible ways the accident happend that you know nothing about, why give him more hatred to read they are already in enough pain!
The lady on the Balcony: She saw the accident and did not even spew hatred, she came across very sympathedic and fair...try taking a cue from her!
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 712918 on June 6, 2008 at 7:06 p.m.
I drive that overpass to Calallen every day and it is very tricky, especially on windy days. Most people do not observe the speed limit, those that do either get tailgated or passed up. I believe the wind could have been a factor.
Everyone should just stop with the public speculation of what happened and keep these gentlemen and their families in their prayers. Regardless of their profession, at this time they are two unfortunate human beings in need of everyone's prayers.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 713008 on June 6, 2008 at 8:47 p.m.
in response to 389468
no
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 713008 on June 6, 2008 at 8:51 p.m.
in response to 401467
he's a great judge
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 713008 on June 6, 2008 at 9:01 p.m.
in response to 240803
i agree...everyone needs to pray for both parties. Leave these people alone...focus on healing, prayer and a happy ending ...lori
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 713008 on June 6, 2008 at 9:08 p.m.
in response to 233106
yes there was a court manager under investigation but it wasn't judge banales court coordinater...and not in his court
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 713008 on June 6, 2008 at 9:22 p.m.
in response to 449075
no he wasn't and you don't know my judge banales..stay focused on prayer and healing ...quick to judge...stay focused
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 713008 on June 6, 2008 at 9:28 p.m.
in response to 712918
i agree...please pray for my judge and the other gentlemen in a positive recovery.....lori
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 237099 on June 6, 2008 at 9:40 p.m.
RE: 712918
He wasn't going towards Calallen - he was traveling on SH 358 and taking the ramp to go towards downtown. If the wind was a problem wouldn't there of been more cars being blown off the roadway-? WHY do you say everyone should STOP speculating on what happened when you yourself are doing the same.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 712918 on June 6, 2008 at 10:22 p.m.
In response to 237099:
Read post 712731 (who witnessed the accident) and 711762. I'm not speculating why don't you try to read the posts again.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 712664 on June 6, 2008 at 10:42 p.m.
in response to 274667
That argument doesn't bear any logic.....
keep the thought, raise you a clue.....
Prayers to the TXDot employee and his family.
Prayers to Judge Banales and his family.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 319029 on June 6, 2008 at 10:59 p.m.
If anyone thinks that I'm saying this because he's a judge, just remember one thing. I'm sure the banks where I was almost hit by this so-called judge have surveillance camera systems, as does the Exxon gas station on the other corner.
Some of you think judges and police chiefs should be held to the same standard as everyone else. Everyone "else" is not a judge or police chief. The low standards of Corpus Christi is what made it what it is today. It's not very pretty.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 254268 on June 7, 2008 at 2:12 a.m.
He killed someone like 20 years ago. How pompous can you be to keep killing people and still get reelected and twist arms to have your wife elected?
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 710237 on June 7, 2008 at 4:42 a.m.
in response to 235519
Well, I think there is so much anomosity towards Judge Banales and of course his wife simply because how they attend to their work and positions. The issues about her moving county funds so her husband could redecorate his new office at City Hall, for him to encourage it, and for her to negotiate with the other commissioners behind the scenes when it came to the vote is the great distractor in all of this. This is what has turned many of the citizens off and this is why, unfortunately, people look upon the Judge and his wife with distrust and disgust. It did not bring out the best in us, I guess, and so people have made their feelings known which they have every right to do so.
Had the Judge and his Commissioner wife handled the above affair differently and not felt so entitled as most citizens felt, I think there would be more compassion towards him. But, it's too late for that. It isn't always the "right way" to go about something when we feel we can control everything and see that we aren't breaking a guideline as in the case of the Judge's office. The Judge and his wife got what they wanted but look at what cost it took on them. I bet they don't feel it was worth it now but this is a lesson to be learned by all public officials.
Yes, I agree, we need to nevertheless pray for everyone. My heart really goes out to Manuel Garcia, the worker, and his family. I am sure this is one of the most horrible events in their life. I am sorry they have to experience it. I am so sorry it had to happen...I am sure the Judge and his wife wished they could control something like this as well as they controlled redecorating the Judge's office.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 709654 on June 7, 2008 at 8:08 a.m.
Uh-oh.
Clear day.
No road hazards.
No inclement weather conditions.
We've all seen the posted signs concerning "workers ahead". Ramps, and their posted signs.
BIG trucks moved 50-yards by mid-sized cars. And not only moved, but pushed up an embankment at that. PUSHED UP. That children takes some hella pushin' by a much lighter object striking a much heavier stationary object. If you think not, try finding a person about 3 x's your body-weight and striking them with enough force to move them roughly 10 feet.
Some of you would do well to consult Newton's Laws as well as bone up on such things like Force, Resistance and other saiient matters
If it were me I'd better be hoping like HELL a stroke or heart attack was something it could be pinned on because anything otherwise I'd likely be going on vacation to Hotel Huntsville.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 699936 on June 7, 2008 at 10:24 p.m.
There is a fund for the txdot workers family to help with expenses while he is in the hospital. Navy Army credit union for txdot employee Martin Garcia. thank you and god bless everyone involved in this accident.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 711760 on June 8, 2008 at 6:17 p.m.
Its sad how he will probably get away with this because of his position. And as far as everyone standing up for him and the sherriff that is just crazy. I chanllenge everyone and the MEDIA to look into a sherriff deputy with the last name of Solis getting terminated because of a vehicle accident. Why doesnt he get the same treatment. Lets see how far this gets and that will show how the system is when even media keeps quiet about some of this stuff.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 459106 on June 8, 2008 at 8:33 p.m.
Okay everyone, there are 3 possible reasons, 1. alcohol related, 2. using the cell phone and not paying attention or 3. Speeding, of which he is known to do quite often. He will not admit to speeding or using the cell phone, so people, don't expect a confession from him. There are ways to find out how fast he was going, or should I say estimate of speed, but what I heard, that is no longer revelent, that law suddenly changed the day of this accident. Mr. Banales, I have seen you at the church driving out of the parking lot like a bat out of hell quite a few times. Tell me Mr. Banales, if you did not have any alcohol in your system, good, but why would you run over this man? Were you going too fast to react and avoid him. Were you distracted by the cell phone, or were you just not paying attention? Will you admit to any of this? I think you should, because if not, that means you did it on purpose? I hope I am wrong, but it has to be one of these 3. You have gone through that route many times, you know that you have to slow down, why did'nt you? Being that you are a judge, you will get away with this, there is no doubt in my mind. I have seen it way too many times in my lifetime. You may be a law abiding citizen and a good judge, but you are human and can make mistakes just like everyone else. So be a man and tell the public the real truth, after all, is'nt that what you ask of the clients, be honest, truthful? Think about it everyone, there is no other explanation, if you have one, let all of us know. Don't get me wrong, I have nothing against the judge, but he almost killed a man because of his negligence.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 243116 on June 8, 2008 at 10:14 p.m.
As all of you may understand, accidents are just that 'Accidents'. There is a lot of speculation as to the cause of the accident. Our main focus should be on the health and welfare of those involved. As a long-time friend of Martin, I hold no ill will towards the judge. Two families were affected. In retrospect, I just wished that there was just a little more coverage on Martin Garcia as there was on Judge Banales in the beginning. I just pray that everything comes out okay for all involved.
Additionally, I don't make it my business to solicit donations but there is a fund already established for Martin as posted earlier. For those who are not fully aware, there is a long and painful road to recovery that lies ahead for him and his family. For those who can, please take a moment to donate. Thank you in advance for your prayers and compassion.
Martin Garcia Fund
c/o Navy Army Federal Credit Union
P.O. Box 81349
Corpus Christi, TX 78468-1349
God Bless Martin and his family through this difficult time.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 713037 on June 8, 2008 at 10:33 p.m.
Judge Banales gave me 60 years in prison for a crime....yes he is known to be a harsh man when it comes to the law. However, this same man after 6 years of recieving my letters and those of my wife, he reduced my sentence to 10 years. I am now with my family again. I wish for the best possible outcome for the victim and the Judge. Let us show a little compassion instead of finger pointing with upturned noses.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 415028 on June 9, 2008 at 9:06 a.m.
I can’t believe almost ALL the articles say ...the car slid off the pavement! WHAT? There was no ice? No rain? Yes, wind is horrible but…you have to speeding to cause any real damage like this. How come they are not speculating that? If it was some John Doe then they would have speculated speeding. Speed had to have played a factor and I wish the news would at least say that it might have been a factor. I really hope the investigation does not end at “the car slid” and crashed into a man and pushed a (super heavy) tractor. That would insult everyone’s intelligence. I have known the Garcia family for years and they are the sweetest family. My prayers are with them.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 709587 on June 10, 2008 at 10 a.m.
My prayers go out to both familys...Does anyone know how the young man is doing?
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 713086 on June 10, 2008 at 11:57 p.m.
My name is Josemanuel Edmundo Banales. I am the eldest son of Manuel and Peggy Banales. As a family, our thoughts and prayers are with the Garcia family and we wish Mr. Garcia a speedy recovery.
I've read the blogs and I would like to thank those of you who have prayed for my father, our family, and the Garcia family as well. We are grateful for your prayers and support.
My parents are political figures in the Corpus Christi community. I've witnessed and endured the attacks on them for 20+ years. Much of the speculation I've read is at best inaccurate and defamatory with out any basis of fact and under the veil of anonymity. I realize cannot keep any one of you from "exercising your first amendment right"; but what I can do is pray.
I will pray that you have the patience to let this investigation run its course. I will pray that you remember that Mr. Garcia and his family are suffering need our compassion. And I will pray that you will look to God and ask for peace. Many of you have never met my parents so I cannot comprehend how there could be so much hate towards them.
I pray that you realize whatever is in your hearts that causes you to direct your hate towards my parents is hurting us all. My ACTS brothers, my family and I have Mr. Garcia and his family, and the community of Corpus Christi in our prayers.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 711114 on June 12, 2008 at 9:19 a.m.
Seven calls for "prayer" are noted in Josemanuel's blog. Certainly one hopes these calls for prayer are heartfelt and not self serving hypocrycy in an effort to obscure the issues and defend his father.
However, instead of generalities by Josemanuel and repeated calls for prayer, specific denial about the allegations would greatly aid the community knowledge, including information about any prior specific automobile accidents.
I will reserve judgment of this case and all cases until he or his father responds to allegations of any other serious accidents and the facts and circumstances involving all of the accidents involving Judge Banales.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 712466 on June 12, 2008 at 9:55 a.m.
my prays to Mr. Garcia and the Judge
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 713120 on June 12, 2008 at 12:58 p.m.
Serious action should be taken. It does not matter that he is a judge. HE is a cruel, mean, uncaring, person who doesn't care if he ruins people's lives. They should have given him a breathalizer among other things to determine the accident. A innocent man is now suffering for banales' carelessness and his entire family is suffering. Is it true that something to this nature happened in August of 1990 and nothing was done about it. Just like if it was a citizen who commited the crime actions would have been taken a long time ago, the person would have been arrested and could not refuse to give blood or take a breathalizer. This really pisses me off due to the fact my husband is serving a very harsh sentence that Banales sentenced him to with no feeling at all. He has a family out here a son who needs him. Did Banales care, no!!!!!!! So we should not feel sorry for him in no form or fashion, now he should be put in the same shoes, I damn sure dont care that he is a judge, the same laws should apply to him as well. Please pray for the Garcia family and by the way Banales should man up with hiss crooked a@* and publicly apologize to the Garcia family even though it will not make adifference in Mr. Garcia's physical health. I can't beleive it the heartless judge nearly took someone's life, I mean literally, he takes lives anyway by giving people hard unnecessary sentences for cases way smaller than the crime he has commited
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 713163 on June 15, 2008 at 12:49 a.m.
in response to 713086
Jose Manuel,
I feel for your father and the TXDOT worker. I myself worked in a public position and found myself under fire for something I did not do. Like your father I know it hurts to be judged by others and presumed guilty just due to the fact public employees, judges, police etc are hated by so many people. At the same time I know that I will only go as far as God wants me and this case your father is now involved in will only go as far as God seems fit.
I think it is a great thing you did by standing by your father. I know that my son standing by me during these times I am going thru means the world to me. I will pray for your family and the hardened hearts of those who wish the worst for your father. God bless you all during these times. I have seen your father in court and always liked to listen to him. He is a very wise man and the public needs to understand we are only human. God bless Mr. Garcia and his family. as well. My heart goes out to them.
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 713155 on June 22, 2008 at 10:36 p.m.
Post 713163 - Why would I feel sorry for someone who caused an accident and is practically unhurt? Why would I feel sorry for someone who does not seem to be held accountable for his actions? You say you found yourself under fire for something you did not do. Are you saying Judge Banales did not hit him?
Reply to this Post | Suggest removal
related links Posted by 713337 on June 24, 2008 at 12:41 a.m.
in response to 713086
Hi Jose Manuel Edmundo Banales,
I guess you don't really know your father otherwise you would know that he is intolerant of anyone who prays and takes religious activities seriously. You mention prayers but more than likely you use these vain and hypocritical words as a smokescreen to further your father's supposed political career. He considers people who go to church on a weekly basis to be religious zealots and ridicules them.
I hope the construction worker makes it okay but I hope justice is served for the actions your father committed...
Best Regards,
Jessie
posted by dannoynted1 at 5:13 AM
0 comments
links to this post
![[Illustration]](http://writ.news.findlaw.com/images/illustrations/e-chair_cropped.jpg)
August 2, 2007